<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<!-- name="GENERATOR" content="github.com/mmarkdown/mmark Mmark Markdown Processor - mmark.miek.nl" -->
<rfc version="3" ipr="trust200902" docName="draft-ramadan-moq-mmt-01" submissionType="IETF" category="std" xml:lang="en" xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude" indexInclude="true">

<front>
<title abbrev="MMT for MoQ">MPEG Media Transport (MMT) Packaging for Media over QUIC</title><seriesInfo value="draft-ramadan-moq-mmt-01" stream="IETF" status="standard" name="Internet-Draft"></seriesInfo>
<author initials="O." surname="Ramadan" fullname="Omar Ramadan"><organization>Blockcast</organization><address><postal><street></street>
</postal><email>omar@blockcast.net</email>
</address></author><date year="2026" month="October" day="26"></date>
<area>wit</area>
<workgroup>moq</workgroup>
<keyword>MMT</keyword>
<keyword>MMTP</keyword>
<keyword>MoQ</keyword>
<keyword>ATSC 3.0</keyword>
<keyword>FEC</keyword>

<abstract>
<t>This document specifies the use of MPEG Media Transport (MMT) as a
container format for Media over QUIC (MoQ).  MMT carries media over
broadcast (ATSC 3.0, ARIB STD-B60), multicast, and unicast
(QUIC/WebTransport) networks.  This specification defines the mapping
of MMT packets to MoQ objects, interaction with Application-Layer FEC,
the derivation of MoQ catalogs from MMTP signaling, and
compatibility considerations for both ATSC 3.0 and ARIB STD-B60
systems.</t>
</abstract>

</front>

<middle>

<section anchor="introduction"><name>Introduction</name>
<t>MPEG Media Transport (MMT) <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> is a transport protocol
designed for delivery of multimedia content over heterogeneous
networks.  MMT is supported as a transport in ATSC 3.0 broadcast
television (Americas, South Korea), and is the basis for ARIB
STD-B60 (Japan).
MMT provides native support for:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>Media Processing Units (MPU, branded &quot;mpuf&quot; in the ISO Base Media
File Format (ISOBMFF) <xref target="ISO.14496-12"></xref>) as the media container,
with structural similarities to fMP4</li>
<li>Application-Layer FEC (AL-FEC) supporting multiple schemes
including RaptorQ and Reed-Solomon</li>
<li>Cross-layer signaling for adaptive streaming</li>
<li>Hybrid delivery combining broadcast and broadband</li>
</ul>
<t>This document defines how MMT-encapsulated media can be transported
over MoQ <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref>, enabling:</t>

<ol spacing="compact">
<li><strong>Broadcast-to-Unicast bridging</strong>: Content from ATSC 3.0 or ARIB STD-B60
broadcasts can be relayed to MoQ subscribers without transcoding</li>
<li><strong>FEC</strong>: MMT's AL-FEC integrates with MoQ FEC repair tracks
per <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref></li>
<li><strong>Multicast promotion</strong>: MoQ clients can receive Source-Specific
Multicast (SSM) directly when available, per <xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref></li>
<li><strong>Broadcast signaling</strong>: Derive MoQ catalogs from MMTP signaling
(Section 12.2)</li>
</ol>

<section anchor="relationship-to-other-moq-media-formats"><name>Relationship to Other MoQ Media Formats</name>
<t>This specification complements existing MoQ packaging formats.  The
MOQT Streaming Format (MSF) <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> carries media
packaged with the Low Overhead Media Container (LOC)
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-loc"></xref>, and CMSF <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> carries media
packaged in the Common Media Application Format (CMAF):</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Format</th>
<th>Container</th>
<th>Primary Use Case</th>
<th>FEC Block Profile</th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td>MSF (LOC)</td>
<td>WebCodecs chunks</td>
<td>Low-latency unicast</td>
<td>&quot;moq-object-v1&quot;</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>CMSF</td>
<td>CMAF fMP4</td>
<td>Adaptive streaming</td>
<td>&quot;moq-object-v1&quot;</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>This spec (MMT)</td>
<td>MMTP + MPU (ISOBMFF)</td>
<td>Broadcast bridge</td>
<td>&quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot;</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t>The last column names the block profile under which <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
protects tracks of each packaging.  Under &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; each FEC
source packet (FEC Type 1) is one source symbol.  Under
&quot;moq-object-v1&quot; each loc or cmaf object whose Object Status is Normal
occupies whole source symbols.</t>
<t>MMT packaging fits these cases:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>Ingesting ATSC 3.0 or ARIB STD-B60 broadcasts</li>
<li>FEC protection is required for multicast delivery</li>
<li>Hybrid broadcast/unicast architectures are deployed</li>
<li>Interoperability with broadcast receivers is needed</li>
</ul>
<t>CMAF packaging (CMSF) fits these cases:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>Content originates as DASH/HLS</li>
<li>No multicast delivery is planned</li>
<li>Interoperability with existing CDN infrastructure is needed</li>
</ul>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="terminology"><name>Terminology</name>
<t>The key words &quot;<bcp14>MUST</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>MUST NOT</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>REQUIRED</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>SHALL</bcp14>&quot;,
&quot;<bcp14>SHALL NOT</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>SHOULD</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>SHOULD NOT</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>RECOMMENDED</bcp14>&quot;,
&quot;<bcp14>NOT RECOMMENDED</bcp14>&quot;, &quot;<bcp14>MAY</bcp14>&quot;, and &quot;<bcp14>OPTIONAL</bcp14>&quot; in this document
are to be interpreted as described in BCP 14 <xref target="RFC2119"></xref> <xref target="RFC8174"></xref> when,
and only when, they appear in all capitals, as shown here.</t>
<t><strong>MMTP</strong>: MMT Protocol - the packet layer of MMT (ISO 23008-1 Clause 9)</t>
<t><strong>MPU</strong>: Media Processing Unit - a generic container for independently
decodable timed or non-timed data (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 3.1.14)</t>
<t><strong>MFU</strong>: Media Fragment Unit - a sample or subsample of timed media
data, or an item of non-timed media data, within an MPU
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.3.1)</t>
<t><strong>AL-FEC</strong>: Application-Layer Forward Error Correction</t>
<t><strong>AU</strong>: Access Unit</t>
<t><strong>SLT</strong>: Service Layer Table - ATSC 3.0 bootstrap signaling</t>
<t><strong>MPT</strong>: MMT Package Table - signaling table containing MMT asset info</t>
<t><strong>PA</strong>: Package Access - the signaling message that carries the
tables a receiver needs to consume a Package, among them the MPT
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.3.2)</t>
<t><strong>MPI</strong>: Media Presentation Information - signalling table carrying
the presentation information document (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.3.8)</t>
</section>

<section anchor="mmt-overview"><name>MMT Overview</name>
<t>MMT uses a layered architecture:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[+---------------------------------------------+
|              Application Layer              |
+---------------------------------------------+
|  MPU (Media Processing Unit)                |
|  +---------+---------+---------+---------+  |
|  |  MFU 0  |  MFU 1  |  MFU 2  |   ...   |  |
|  | (IDR)   | (P)     | (P)     |         |  |
|  +---------+---------+---------+---------+  |
+---------------------------------------------+
|  MMTP (MMT Protocol)                        |
|  +-----------------------------------------+|
|  | MMTP Header | Payload (MPU fragment)    ||
|  | 12 bytes    | Variable                  ||
|  +-----------------------------------------+|
+---------------------------------------------+
|  Transport: UDP/IP (broadcast/multicast)    |
|             QUIC/WebTransport (unicast)     |
+---------------------------------------------+
]]></artwork>

<section anchor="mmtp-header-format"><name>MMTP Header Format</name>

<artwork><![CDATA[MMTP Header (12 bytes minimum) {
  Version (2),
  Packet Counter Flag (C) (1),
  FEC_type (FEC) (2),
  Reserved (1),
  Extension Flag (X) (1),
  RAP Flag (R) (1),
  Reserved (2),
  type (6),
  Packet ID (16),
  Timestamp (32),
  Packet Sequence Number (32),
  [Packet Counter (32)],       // Present if C=1 (never: C=0)
  [Header Extension (..)]      // Present if X=1
}
]]></artwork>
<t>The fixed fields sum to 96 bits (three 32-bit words).  Byte 0 is
version(2) | packet_counter_flag(1) | FEC_type(2) | reserved(1) |
extension_flag(1) | RAP_flag(1); byte 1 is reserved(2) |
type(6), i.e. the packet type occupies the low six bits of
the second byte (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.2).</t>
<t>Senders MUST set all reserved bits in the MMTP packet header to zero.
Receivers MUST ignore their values after validating the header; they
MUST NOT assign private semantics to reserved bits.</t>
<t>Every packet of an MMTP packet flow -- media, repair, and signaling
packets alike, on every delivery path -- MUST set the packet counter
flag C to 0, so no packet carries the Packet Counter field.
<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.2.3 requires all packets of an MMTP flow to
share one setting of C; this profile fixes that setting at 0.  The
MMTP packet header is therefore 12 bytes unless X = 1 adds a header
extension.</t>
<t>This document profiles MMTP version 0 (<tt>V = 00</tt>) of
ISO/IEC 23008-1:2023 as amended by Amd 1:2025.  A packet whose version
is not <tt>00</tt> MUST be rejected before its <tt>type</tt> field is parsed: version
1 uses a different type-field layout and is not defined by this
profile.  The <tt>C = 0</tt> requirement above is also a conformance gate;
packets with <tt>C = 1</tt> MUST be rejected.  An <tt>X = 1</tt> header extension is
parsed according to its declared length, but this document defines no
additional version or packet-counter semantics.</t>
<t>Key fields for MoQ mapping:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li><strong>Packet ID</strong>: Maps to MoQ track within namespace.  This document
reserves packet_id 0 for the MMTP signaling flow: MMTP packets of
packet type 0x02 carrying signaling messages, such as the PA message
of a multicast endpoint flow (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 5) and the
AL-FEC message of Section 8.3.  No MoQ track is advertised for
the signaling flow, but an mmtp source track MAY carry its AL-FEC
message as an object (Section 8).  An MMTP packet carrying media
(packet type 0x00) or a repair symbol (packet type 0x03) MUST NOT use
packet_id 0; a
track's packet_id is in the range 1..65535, and on multicast
delivery it is the <tt>packetId</tt> the endpoint advertises for the
track (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.1).  On every delivery path, a
receiver MUST NOT deliver an MMTP packet on packet_id 0 to a media
or repair decoder, including one received as the payload of an
object of a media or repair track: a receiver that processes MMTP
signaling reads it as a signaling message, and any other receiver
discards it (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 5 states the same rule for
every unlisted packet_id on multicast)</li>
<li><strong>Timestamp</strong>: UTC wallclock send time in the NTP short format of
<xref target="RFC5905"></xref> Section 6 (32 bits: 16-bit seconds and 16-bit fraction,
relative to the NTP epoch), carried inside the object payload.  MoQ
Transport defines no per-object timestamp field; receivers needing the send time read
it from the preserved MMTP packet header.  Because the seconds part
is 16 bits, the value wraps every 65 536 seconds (about 18.2
hours): it identifies the send time modulo that period and MUST NOT
be interpreted as an absolute wallclock time without an out-of-band
era reference.  It is used for packet delivery and jitter
measurement and is never media time: not a decoding timestamp,
presentation timestamp, duration, media-clock epoch, or
movie-fragment identifier</li>
<li><strong>Packet Sequence Number</strong>: per-<tt>packet_id</tt>, incremented by one modulo
2^32 across the flow (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.2.3); carried inside
the object payload for wrap-aware MMTP-layer loss/ordering detection.
It is not the MoQ Object ID.  Object IDs number the objects of a
group in source order, starting at zero in each group (Section 4.6).</li>
<li><strong>FEC Type</strong>: 0=no AL-FEC, 1=AL-FEC source packet (exactly one
4-byte Source FEC Payload ID trails the packet, <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 8.5), 2=AL-FEC repair packet for FEC payload ID mode 0,
3=AL-FEC repair packet for FEC payload ID mode 1 (not used by this
mapping) (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.2.3)</li>
<li><strong>RAP Flag</strong>: 1 indicates Random Access Point.  On a track that the
catalog protects with a keyframe overlay, a packet with RAP_flag 1
also carries the overlay's SS_ID in a header extension of type
0x8B01 (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 8.5.1)</li>
</ul>
<t>A signaling packet (packet type 0x02, on packet_id 0) MUST carry its
messages in the signaling message mode of <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Clause 9.3.4: its MMTP payload begins with the 2-byte payload header
of Clause 9.3.4.2:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[Signaling Message Payload Header {
  f_i (2),                    // fragmentation indicator
  RES (4),                    // reserved, set to 0
  H (1),                      // 1: each MSG_length is 32 bits
  A (1),                      // aggregation_flag
  frag_count (8),             // fragmentation counter
}
]]></artwork>
<t>When A = 1, a MSG_length field of 16 bits, or 32 bits when H = 1,
precedes each aggregated message; when A = 0 no MSG_length field is
present.  The signaling message follows (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Clause 10.2), beginning with its message_id.  A packet that carries
one complete signaling message without aggregation has f_i = 00,
A = 0, and frag_count = 0, and its sender sets H = 0 (H has no
effect when A = 0), so its payload header is the two bytes 0x00 0x00
and the message_id immediately follows them.  A receiver ignores H
when A = 0 and parses the header field by field, never by matching
those two bytes.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="moq-object-mapping"><name>MoQ Object Mapping</name>

<section anchor="track-structure"><name>Track Structure</name>
<t>An MMT stream maps to MoQ tracks as follows:</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>MMT Component</th>
<th>MoQ Mapping</th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td>Package</td>
<td>Namespace</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>Asset, by Packet ID (video)</td>
<td>Track &quot;video&quot;</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>Asset, by Packet ID (audio)</td>
<td>Track &quot;audio&quot;</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>MPU (one MPU per group)</td>
<td>Group; number derived from media time (Section 4.4.1)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>MPU data unit (FT=0, FT=1, or FT=2)</td>
<td>Subgroup ID</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>MMTP packet (fragment) within a data unit</td>
<td>Object; Object IDs count the group's objects from 0 in source order (Section 4.6)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>AL-FEC signaling message (OPTIONAL, packet_id 0)</td>
<td>Object in Subgroup 0 immediately before FT=0 (Section 8)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>AL-FEC repair</td>
<td>Track &quot;video/repair&quot;</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t><xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 6 maps each object to a new stream.  An
mmtp track does not follow that rule.  It maps each MPU
data unit to one subgroup (Section 4.3), and the objects of a
subgroup share one stream (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 2.2),
so each data unit's fragments travel in order on one stream.  An mmtp
track keeps the Group and Object numbering of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Sections 6.1 and 6.2: Group numbers are unique and increase
monotonically (Section 4.4.1), and Object IDs start at zero in each
group and increase by one (Section 4.6).</t>
</section>

<section anchor="object-payload"><name>Object Payload</name>
<t>Each MoQ object carries one complete MMTP packet:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[MoQ Object Payload {
  MMTP Packet Header (12+ bytes),
  MMTP Payload (MPU-mode payload header,
                then an FT=0, FT=1, or FT=2 data-unit fragment),
  [Source FEC Payload ID (32)],   // trails FEC Type=1 packets
}
]]></artwork>
<t>The object payload begins at byte zero of the preserved MMTP packet
header.  It has no MoQ-private envelope, length prefix, harness prefix,
or other undocumented bytes before that header.  For an FEC Type 1
packet, the Source FEC Payload ID and any profile-defined MMTP header
extensions remain in their specified wire locations.  No object-layer
prefix, suffix, or private replacement for those fields is permitted.
When <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> requires the FEC Source Info Object Property (type
<tt>0x11</tt>), its value remains the four-byte, network-byte-order <tt>SS_ID</tt>
defined by that document; the property is object metadata and is not
inserted into this payload.</t>
<t>The one exception is the OPTIONAL AL-FEC signaling object of
Section 8: its payload is a complete MMTP signaling packet (packet
type 0x02) on packet_id 0 with FEC Type 0.  Its MMTP payload is the
signaling message payload header of Section 3.1 followed by one
complete AL-FEC message (f_i = 00, A = 0), rather than an MPU-mode
payload header and data-unit fragment, and it carries no Source FEC
Payload ID.  No other object on an mmtp source track uses packet
type 0x02 or packet_id 0.</t>
<t>Throughout this document, &quot;MMTP packet&quot; means the header-included
wire unit and &quot;MMTP payload&quot; means the bytes that follow the packet
header, per <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>.  Both MMTP header layers are always
preserved: the packet header carries the FEC Type, RAP Flag, and
timestamp, and the MPU-mode payload header (the first bytes of the
MMTP payload) carries the Fragmentation Indicator and MPU sequence
number that receivers and the FEC layer depend on.  A publisher that
wishes to deliver raw ISOBMFF fragments without MMTP encapsulation
publishes the track with CMAF packaging <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref>
instead.  In this profile an MPU can contain one or more ISOBMFF movie
fragments: FT=1 carries one movie fragment's metadata and each FT=2
data unit carries one whole sample or one producer-authored subsample
of a sample (Section 5.2.1).</t>
</section>

<section anchor="group-boundaries"><name>Group Boundaries</name>
<t>This section defines the object layout of mfu mode
(<tt>mmtpMode: &quot;mfu&quot;</tt>, Section 12.1).</t>
<t>Group boundaries align with MPU boundaries, and subgroup boundaries
align with MPU data-unit boundaries:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>Each group contains all objects of exactly one MPU: a change of MPU
sequence number starts a new group, numbered per Section 4.4.1.</li>
<li>Subgroup 0 of each group carries exactly one complete FT=0 MPU
metadata packet.  Its data unit contains the authored initialization
boxes, including <tt>ftyp</tt>, <tt>mmpu</tt>, and <tt>moov</tt>, and uses FI=0.  When the
publisher carries the OPTIONAL AL-FEC signaling object of Section 8,
that object is in Subgroup 0 of the same group and is the object
immediately before the FT=0 object; Subgroup 0 then carries exactly
these two objects.  No other object precedes FT=0, and a group
carries at most one signaling object.</li>
<li>Subgroups 1..M each carry exactly one subsequent MPU data unit in
authored order.  An FT=1 movie-fragment-metadata data unit is one
complete FI=0 object.  An FT=2 timed sample is either one FI=0 object
or an FI=1, zero-or-more FI=2, FI=3 object chain.  A timed sample
whose media exceeds one data unit's capacity is carried as a
contiguous run of producer-authored subsample data units
(Section 5.2.1), one subgroup per subsample data unit, in ascending
<tt>offset</tt> order.  Section 5.2 defines the only permitted
fragmentation state machine.</li>
<li>A timed MPU MUST publish its single FT=0 metadata data unit before
any FT=1 or FT=2 data unit; only the OPTIONAL signaling object of
Section 8 may precede FT=0.  It then MUST publish each FT=1
data unit before every FT=2 sample or subsample that references that movie
fragment.  If an MPU contains multiple movie fragments, the sequence
repeats as FT=1 followed by its FT=2 samples.  A receiver MUST
validate and process subgroups in ascending Subgroup ID, not network
arrival order, and MUST NOT admit an FT=2 sample before its FT=1
metadata: concurrently delivered subgroups MAY arrive in any order
and are buffered until their turn.  A missing or duplicate FT=0 invalidates the group; a gap,
duplicate data-unit identity, or invalid FT=1/FT=2 sequence in that
logical order invalidates the affected movie fragment.  A receiver
MUST NOT infer the missing structure.  The signaling object is not a
data unit: its presence or absence does not affect this validation,
and a signaling object anywhere other than immediately before FT=0
in Subgroup 0, or a second one in a group, invalidates the group.</li>
<li>The FI=0 or FI=1 object that begins the first FT=2 sample of each
timed group -- for a subsample-partitioned sample, the object that
begins its offset-0 data unit -- MUST have RAP Flag = 1.</li>
</ul>
<t>The MPU sequence number remains present in-band (in the MMTP payload
header of every MPU fragment) and delimits which packets belong to the
same group, but it is not the MoQ Group number.  Publishers MUST NOT
copy the MPU sequence number into the Group number, and subscribers
MUST NOT derive media time or switching decisions from it.  (The MPU
sequence number is a per-Asset counter.  It starts at zero for the first
MPU in an Asset and increments by one for every following MPU
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 7.3.3), but it is
Asset-local: independently packetized renditions need not assign the
same MPU number to the same media instant.  Counter-based group
numbering therefore cannot satisfy the switching-set alignment
requirements of Section 4.4.)</t>
<t>For an ISOBMFF source, the publisher MUST preserve initialization in
FT=0, MUST copy the authored <tt>moof</tt> and the original <tt>mdat</tt> prefix
through the byte before the first media sample byte-for-byte into FT=1,
and MUST copy the referenced sample bytes byte-for-byte and without
transformation into FT=2.  A receiver can therefore reconstruct the
authored movie fragment without synthesizing box fields, sample timing,
or media bytes (Section 5.1).</t>
<t>Mapping each data unit to its own subgroup makes a complete metadata
unit or sample the unit of in-order delivery, loss, and FEC.  A
publisher MUST send the objects of an mmtp track in subgroups, not as
datagrams: a datagram object belongs to no subgroup
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 2.2) and cannot carry this
mapping.  Subgroups can be delivered concurrently, and a subgroup can
still be lost, for example when its stream is reset on a delivery
timeout (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Sections 5.2 and 11.3.2); the
resulting gap invalidates the affected movie fragment rather than
authorizing inferred metadata, timing, or cadence.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="switching-sets"><name>Switching Sets</name>
<t>When multiple tracks represent alternative renditions of the same
media (e.g., an adaptive bitrate (ABR) ladder), they form a
switching set: a set of alternate tracks that MUST be time-aligned per
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 4.2 (the same construct that
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> Section 3.2 applies to CMAF tracks).  MoQ
Group boundaries MUST be media-time-aligned across all tracks of a
switching set so that subscribers can switch at group boundaries.
Tracks with equal group durations MUST carry the same Group number for the
same media interval.  Only an intra-only mmtp track can have a
shorter group duration than the other tracks, under the exception of
Section 4.4.2, which also defines its Group number mapping.  A cmaf
member keeps equal group durations and the Group number alignment
that <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> Section 3.2 requires.  The switch is
without discontinuity when the MPUs are closed groups of pictures
(GOPs).  On a join or switch at a Group boundary, leading pictures (Section 4.4.1)
that reference the preceding Group are not decodable, and presentation
of the new track begins at its RAP.  If the old track's next MPU has
leading pictures, neither track has decodable pictures for their
presentation interval, and the receiver conceals that gap.</t>
<t>Switching-set membership is declared in the catalog via the
per-track field:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[altGroup (OPTIONAL, unsigned integer)
]]></artwork>
<t>defined by <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.12: an integer
identifying a group of tracks that are alternate versions of one
another.  Two tracks are members of the same switching set if and only if both
carry the <tt>altGroup</tt> field and the values are equal.  A track that
omits <tt>altGroup</tt> is a member of no switching set, and the
switching-set requirements of this section do not bind it.  A repair
track (Section 8.2) carries no <tt>altGroup</tt>.  It is not an alternate
rendition, and its Groups are FEC blocks (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.5),
not media-time-aligned Groups.  A subscriber finds the repair tracks
of the rendition it selects through that rendition's
<tt>fec.repairTrack</tt> and the <tt>depends</tt> fields of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 5.1.1.</t>

<section anchor="group-number-formula"><name>Group Number Formula</name>
<t>The Group number of every mmtp-packaged track MUST be computed from
media time by the formula in this section.  This single definition is
what makes group boundaries align across the renditions of a
switching set.  FEC interleave timing is independent of this grouping;
Section 7.1 does not derive FEC block boundaries or a number of Groups
per FEC block from this formula:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[relative_ticks = ticks - presentationAnchorTicks
group_number = floor(relative_ticks / groupDurationTicks)
]]></artwork>
<t>where:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li><tt>ticks</tt> is the presentation timestamp (PTS) of the MPU's first AU in
decode order, expressed in the track's <tt>timescale</tt> (Hz, Section
4.4.2) as a signed integer.  That AU is first in the MPU payload, as
ISO/IEC 23008-1 requires, and is the MPU's RAP (Section 4.3).
Leading pictures, which follow the RAP in decode order but present
before it, do not select <tt>ticks</tt>, even when they present within the
preceding MPU's Group interval.</li>
<li><tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> is the per-track group duration expressed
in the same <tt>timescale</tt>, as a positive integer.  The catalog
signals it either directly or through an exact millisecond
conversion as specified in Section 4.4.2.</li>
<li><tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt> is the signed timestamp in this track's
<tt>timescale</tt> that corresponds to presentation time zero.  It includes
the publisher's edit-list, encoder-priming, and composition-time
decisions, and MUST be applied before the formula.  A track that is
intended to be rendered with another audio or video track MUST signal
this field; a track that is not part of a synchronized presentation
MAY omit it and use zero as its local origin.</li>
</ul>
<t>The publisher MUST choose <tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt> no later than the
smallest <tt>ticks</tt> value of the MPUs it admits for the track.  If an
MPU's <tt>ticks</tt> is earlier than the anchor, the publisher MUST reject
that MPU.  Before the first group is published, the publisher MAY
instead revise the catalog anchor and validate the complete initial
input again; after publication, the anchor is immutable for that track
instance.  It MUST NOT clamp the Group number to zero.  The <tt>floor</tt> in
the formula is mathematical floor (floor division), not truncation
towards zero.  With the anchor requirement, every admitted MPU has a
non-negative <tt>relative_ticks</tt> value.  The requirement binds <tt>ticks</tt>
only; a leading picture of an admitted MPU can present before the
anchor.</t>
<t>Timeline origin: <tt>ticks</tt> is measured on the track's media
presentation timeline; <tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt> maps that track to
the shared presentation timeline.  For every set of audio and video
tracks intended to be rendered together, the publisher MUST choose one
presentation origin and MUST signal an anchor for each track such that</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[presentation_time = (ticks - presentationAnchorTicks) / timescale
]]></artwork>
<t>has the same rational value for samples representing the same media
instant.  This is a media-time relation, not an NTP or wall-clock
relation, and it is not the <tt>Timestamp</tt> field of the MMTP packet header
(Section 3.1).  For
ISOBMFF-derived MPU content, the anchor is applied to the composition
timeline after edit-list and priming adjustments.  All tracks of a
switching set MUST use the same presentation origin as well.  A
publisher that resets the timeline (a timeline discontinuity) MUST
reset it identically, at the same media instant, across every affected
audio, video, and switching-set track.  A discontinuity on an existing
track does not reset its Group number sequence.</t>
<t>This Group anchor is a MoQ scheduling and switching key only.  ISO/IEC
23008-1 presentation timing remains authoritative: the presentation time
of an MPU is signaled by the presentation information (or the
<tt>mpu_timestamp_descriptor</tt> when no presentation information is present),
with any applicable <tt>elst</tt> offset, and is not rewritten by this Group
number calculation.</t>
<t>For each track, when the MPU changes, the computed Group number MUST be
strictly greater than the Group number of the preceding admitted MPU.
The publisher MUST NOT put two different MPUs in one Group, reuse a
Group number, or alter authored timestamps to satisfy this rule.  A
publisher that restarts or declares a discontinuity MUST retain the last
Group number for the existing track instance and resume with a greater
number; numeric gaps are allowed.  The publisher SHOULD signal the
skipped numbers with the PRIOR_GROUP_ID_GAP Object Property
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 10.8), as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 6.1 recommends.  If it cannot resume with a greater number
while preserving the formula and authored timing, it MUST close that
track instance and
start a new track with a distinct (namespace, track name) pair before
emitting the reset MPU.  That new identity is the Group-number
scope for the restarted stream; it MUST NOT be presented as a
continuation of the old track.  Group-number state is transport state;
this document defines no new catalog field for it.</t>
<t>Because its Group numbers follow media time, an mmtp publisher cannot
start a Group early.  It MUST NOT set the DYNAMIC_GROUPS Track
Property (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 10.6) to 1.</t>
<t>For two tracks A and B, a receiver can verify that timestamps describe
the same presentation instant without floating-point conversion:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[(ticksA - presentationAnchorTicksA) * timescaleB ==
    (ticksB - presentationAnchorTicksB) * timescaleA
]]></artwork>
<t>The group-duration agreement rule in this section applies after the
same anchor conversion.  Consequently, equal rational values of
<tt>groupDurationTicks / timescale</tt> and correctly paired
<tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt> values are what align 30-fps video with
audio; per-track <tt>timescale</tt> and <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> values alone do
not establish synchronization.</t>
<t>All arithmetic is in integers: <tt>relative_ticks</tt> and <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt>
are integers, <tt>floor(relative_ticks / groupDurationTicks)</tt> is integer division,
and implementations MUST NOT compute the group number in floating
point or apply any tolerance.  An input held in another unit
(seconds, milliseconds, a different timescale) MUST be converted to
an exact integer tick count before the formula is applied; if that
conversion is not exact, the publisher's timescale or group-duration
choice is wrong (Section 4.4.2) -- implementations MUST NOT round to
compensate.</t>
<t>For ISOBMFF content, authored composition timestamps use the media
track's <tt>mdhd</tt> timescale.  If that differs from the catalog <tt>timescale</tt>,
the publisher MUST convert the adjusted composition timestamps by the
exact ratio <tt>timescale / mdhd.timescale</tt> before applying this formula.
It MUST reject a timestamp that is not an integer in the selected
catalog clock; it MUST NOT relabel media ticks as asset-clock ticks.</t>
<t>Worked example.  A switching set of two video renditions of the same
content: rendition A with <tt>timescale: 90000</tt>, rendition B with
<tt>timescale: 44100</tt>, both with <tt>presentationAnchorTicks: 0</tt> and
<tt>groupDurationMs: 2000</tt> in the catalog (Section 4.4.2).  The sample
that is 10.5 seconds into the shared presentation timeline has an
integer timestamp in both timescales:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[A: groupDurationTicks = 2000 * 90000 / 1000 = 180000
B: groupDurationTicks = 2000 * 44100 / 1000 =  88200

Same media instant, t = 10.5 s on the shared timeline:
A: relative_ticks = 945000 -> floor(945000 / 180000) = 5
B: relative_ticks = 463050 -> floor(463050 /  88200) = 5
]]></artwork>
<t>Both renditions place the instant in group 5.  No intermediate value
is shared between the two computations -- only the integer results
agree -- which is exactly the property group-boundary switching
requires.</t>
<t>Negative authored timestamps use the same rule and are not clamped.  For
one 90 kHz track with <tt>groupDurationTicks: 180000</tt>, choose the shared
presentation anchor <tt>presentationAnchorTicks: -180000</tt>, which is earlier
than the <tt>ticks</tt> of the first admitted MPU:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[MPU 0 ticks = -90000: relative_ticks =  90000 -> group 0
MPU 1 ticks =  90000: relative_ticks = 270000 -> group 1
]]></artwork>
<t>The negative authored PTS therefore maps to group 0 through the shared
earlier anchor.  A catalog with the same samples and
<tt>presentationAnchorTicks: 0</tt> is invalid for this profile; the publisher
rejects MPU 0 instead of mapping it to group 0.</t>
<t>With reordered samples, the first AU in decode order selects the
Group number.  This example lists the authored PTS values of the first
three AUs of two consecutive MPUs in decode order.  MPU 0 is a closed
GOP.  MPU 1 is an open GOP: its RAP presents at 180000, and its two
leading pictures present before it, inside Group 0's interval:</t>

<sourcecode type="json"><![CDATA[{
  "timescale": 90000,
  "presentationAnchorTicks": 0,
  "groupDurationTicks": 180000,
  "mpuSamplePtsInDecodeOrder": [
    [0, 6000, 3000],
    [180000, 174000, 177000]
  ],
  "ticks": [0, 180000],
  "groupNumbers": [0, 1]
}
]]></sourcecode>
<t><tt>ticks</tt> is the first entry of each MPU's list.  Selecting the minimum
presented PTS instead would give <tt>ticks</tt> 0 and 174000, both in Group 0,
which violates the strictly-greater rule above.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="catalog-signaling-of-group-duration"><name>Catalog Signaling of Group Duration</name>
<t>For a subscriber to apply the formula in Section 4.4.1, the catalog
MUST publish the group duration for every mmtp-packaged track.
The catalog publishes either the millisecond form or the exact tick
form defined here:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[groupDurationMs (REQUIRED unless groupDurationTicks is present,
                positive unsigned integer, milliseconds)
]]></artwork>
<t>The timescale is the MSF <tt>timescale</tt> field (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 5.2.21), resolved per the track's <tt>packaging</tt> value
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.4; this document adds <tt>mmtp</tt>,
Section 12.1):</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th><tt>packaging</tt></th>
<th>Timescale source</th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td><tt>mmtp</tt></td>
<td>The <tt>timescale</tt> field, REQUIRED for mmtp tracks (Section 12.1); absence is a catalog error, and the 90 000 <tt>asset_timescale</tt> default of <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.3.9.3 does not apply.</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>cmaf</tt></td>
<td>The <tt>timescale</tt> field.  <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.21 makes it optional, so this document makes it REQUIRED for any cmaf track to which this section applies (a member of a switching set governed by Section 4.4.1); leaving it unset on such a track is a catalog error.</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>loc</tt></td>
<td>The <tt>timescale</tt> field.  As for cmaf, this document makes it REQUIRED for any loc track to which this section applies; leaving it unset on such a track is a catalog error.  When the publisher also sends the TIMESCALE Property (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-loc"></xref> Section 2.3.1.2) on such a track, its value MUST equal the field.</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>(unrecognized <tt>packaging</tt>)</td>
<td>1 000 000 (microseconds).  This row covers track entries whose <tt>packaging</tt> value is unrecognized; the convention is fixed by this document and does not derive from <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref>.  A track entry without <tt>packaging</tt> is malformed (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.4) and fails catalog validation (Section 6.1, step 1).</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t>When <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> is absent, conversion is
<tt>groupDurationTicks = groupDurationMs * timescale / 1000</tt>.  The
catalog publisher MUST choose a <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> such that the
resulting tick count is a positive integer and the conversion is exact
(i.e. <tt>(groupDurationMs * timescale) % 1000 == 0</tt>).  If this cannot be
satisfied, or if the intended cadence is not an integer number of
milliseconds, the catalog MUST publish ticks directly via the exact
tick field:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[groupDurationTicks (OPTIONAL, positive unsigned integer)
]]></artwork>
<t>If both <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> and <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> are present,
<tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> wins and <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> is informational; it is
not used in the conversion and need not have an exact millisecond
conversion.  Cases where the override is required include:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>An MPU group duration at a 30-per-second cadence
(<tt>1/30 s = 33.333... ms</tt>): expressing this in integer ms is
impossible.  If the track <tt>timescale</tt> is divisible by 30, publishers
set <tt>groupDurationTicks: timescale / 30</tt> directly (e.g. <tt>3000</tt> at
90 000 Hz, <tt>1500</tt> at 45 000 Hz).  A timescale not divisible by 30
cannot represent this cadence as an integer tick count and MUST be
changed or rejected for this profile; it MUST NOT be rounded.</li>
<li>Audio sample-rate timescales not divisible by 1000 Hz, such as
44 100 Hz: a 333 ms field would imply
<tt>333 x 44 100 / 1000 = 14 685.3</tt> ticks.  A publisher whose authored
cadence is the exact integral cadence of 14 685 ticks MUST publish
<tt>groupDurationTicks: 14685</tt> (about 332.993 ms); it MUST NOT claim
that this preserves an exact 333 ms duration.  A publisher that
requires exactly 333 ms MUST choose a compatible timescale or reject
that cadence.</li>
</ul>
<t>For example, this catalog uses the exact 30-per-second cadence on a
44 100 Hz track.  It omits <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> because 33.333... ms is
not an integer millisecond value:</t>

<sourcecode type="json"><![CDATA[{
  "version": "draft-01",
  "tracks": [{
    "name": "video-30fps",
    "packaging": "mmtp",
    "isLive": true,
    "mmtpMode": "mfu",
    "timescale": 44100,
    "presentationAnchorTicks": 0,
    "groupDurationTicks": 1470,
    "codec": "avc1.64001f",
    "framerate": 30,
    "bitrate": 2000000
  }]
}
]]></sourcecode>
<t>Switching-set agreement: every track in the same switching set MUST
publish the same effective group duration as a rational number of
seconds.  Raw <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> values need not be equal when track
timescales differ.  For tracks A and B, subscribers validate exact
equality with integer arithmetic:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[A.groupDurationTicks * B.timescale ==
    B.groupDurationTicks * A.timescale
]]></artwork>
<t>One exception applies, to mmtp tracks only.  An mmtp track is
intra-only when its <tt>framerate</tt> field is present and its group
duration is one frame period at that rate:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[groupDurationTicks * framerate == timescale
]]></artwork>
<t>Because <tt>framerate</tt> need not be an integer (29.97), this comparison is
made within a relative tolerance of 10^-3 of <tt>timescale</tt>; a GOP track
misses it by a factor of at least two.  The tolerance only classifies
a track as intra-only.  It never enters Group number arithmetic: the
remainder test below, the quotient n, and every Group number use
exact integers, and Section 4.4.1 forbids any tolerance there.  Every
other track in the switching set, including every track whose
<tt>packaging</tt> is not <tt>mmtp</tt>, is a GOP track.  Exact equality above is
required between all GOP tracks.  An intra-only track I MAY instead publish a shorter
group duration that divides that of the GOP tracks a whole number of
times.  For every GOP track G in the switching set:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[(G.groupDurationTicks * I.timescale) %
    (I.groupDurationTicks * G.timescale) == 0
]]></artwork>
<t>Since an intra-only track has a group boundary at every frame, each GOP
group boundary is also one of its group boundaries, and switching
remains group-aligned.  With quotient
<tt>n = (G.groupDurationTicks * I.timescale) / (I.groupDurationTicks *
G.timescale)</tt> and a shared presentation anchor, Group g of G starts at
the same instant as Group g * n of I.  This mapping is the alternate
mechanism that <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 4.2 requires for
time-aligned tracks whose Group IDs differ at the same instant.  A
subscriber can therefore switch
from G to I at any G group boundary.  It can switch from I to G only at
an I group whose number is a multiple of n.  Each intra-only track is
checked only against the GOP tracks, so switching between two
intra-only tracks of one switching set is group-aligned only at GOP
track group boundaries.  The exception does not
apply to a switching set with no GOP track: intra-only tracks with no
GOP peer still require exact equality.</t>
<t>For example, an mmtp 15 fps intra-only base track with <tt>timescale: 90000</tt> and
<tt>groupDurationTicks: 6000</tt> may share a switching set with a 15 fps GOP
track with <tt>timescale: 1000000</tt> and <tt>groupDurationTicks: 1000000</tt>,
because <tt>1000000 * 90000 = 15 * (6000 * 1000000)</tt>.  With
<tt>groupDurationTicks: 1050000</tt> on the GOP track the remainder is non-zero
and the catalog is invalid.  Two GOP tracks with group durations of 2 s
and 1 s are invalid even though one nests in the other.</t>
<t>Subscribers SHOULD validate this at catalog load and, on disagreement,
SHOULD reject the catalog and signal a catalog-validation error to the
application.  Subscribers that proceed despite disagreement are
non-conformant for switching across the affected tracks; ABR transitions
on such tracks will produce group-boundary discontinuities.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="catalog-signaling-of-keyframe-interval"><name>Catalog Signaling of Keyframe Interval</name>
<t>The group duration above describes the cadence of MMTP media groups
(one MPU per group, Section 4.3).  It does not describe whether an MPU
contains additional keyframes after its required group-start random
access point.  This document defines an OPTIONAL per-track field for
the cadence of all keyframes, which the repair policy of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 11.4.1 uses to classify FEC blocks:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[keyframeIntervalMs (OPTIONAL, unsigned integer, milliseconds)
]]></artwork>
<t><tt>keyframeIntervalMs</tt> is the interval between consecutive video
keyframes, in integer milliseconds.  It is distinct from
<tt>groupDurationMs</tt>: <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> is the duration of
one MPU/group, whereas <tt>keyframeIntervalMs</tt> describes every keyframe,
including any additional keyframes inside an MPU.  When the only
keyframes are the required group-start RAPs and group duration is
constant, the two values are equal; additional RAPs can make the
keyframe interval shorter.  The field applies to video tracks only; a
publisher that cannot determine the cadence simply omits it.</t>
<t>Its absence is not a catalog error:
subscribers MUST NOT reject a catalog solely because it is missing,
and a receiver MUST NOT substitute a locally chosen or observed
cadence for it.  When present, <tt>keyframeIntervalMs</tt> MUST be a
positive integer; a zero value is a catalog error.</t>
<t>The repair policy of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 11.4.1 relies on a published
keyframe interval to exclude keyframes from part of a group, so when
the field is present it binds every keyframe of the track: the publisher MUST NOT emit a
keyframe other than at a group start or a whole number of intervals
after one.  A publisher whose encoder can place keyframes off that
cadence, for example at scene cuts, omits the field.</t>
<t>As with the group duration, the integer-millisecond form cannot
express a keyframe cadence whose tick count is non-integer on the
track's timescale.  A publisher MAY publish an exact override:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[keyframeIntervalTicks (OPTIONAL, unsigned integer)
]]></artwork>
<t>expressed in the same timescale as <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt> (Section 4.4.2,
selected by the track's <tt>packaging</tt>).  If both
<tt>keyframeIntervalMs</tt> and <tt>keyframeIntervalTicks</tt> are present,
<tt>keyframeIntervalTicks</tt> wins.  Unlike
<tt>groupDurationTicks</tt>, this document places no switching-set agreement
requirement on the keyframe interval: it is a per-track hint,
and tracks in a switching set MAY carry different keyframe cadences.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="init-segment-signaling"><name>Init Segment Signaling</name>
<t>Publishers signal MPU metadata inline as the complete FT=0 object in
Subgroup 0 of every group (Section 4.3), preceded in that subgroup only
by the OPTIONAL AL-FEC signaling object of Section 8.  Its data unit contains the
authored initialization boxes, including <tt>ftyp</tt>, <tt>mmpu</tt>, and <tt>moov</tt>.</t>
<t>In addition, publishers SHOULD carry decoder initialization data in
the catalog, using the mechanism of the base catalog that
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> Section 3.1 also uses for CMAF headers.  The
data is an entry of the root <tt>initDataList</tt> array
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.1.7) whose <tt>type</tt> is &quot;inline&quot; and
whose <tt>data</tt> is the base64 encoding of an ISOBMFF initialization
segment (<tt>ftyp</tt> + <tt>moov</tt>) sufficient to initialize the decoder for
the track (including the codec configuration record, e.g. avcC or
hvcC).  The track's <tt>initRef</tt> field (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 5.2.13) holds that entry's <tt>id</tt>.  This lets a subscriber
initialize its decoder at catalog load, before the first FT=0 MPU
metadata object arrives, removing one delivery round trip from the
join path (Section 6.1).  A receiver ignores an <tt>initRef</tt> that names
no entry, or names an entry whose <tt>type</tt> is not &quot;inline&quot;, and joins
without catalog initialization data.</t>
<t>Catalog initialization data is a join optimization, not a replacement
for in-band metadata: the per-group FT=0 MPU metadata remains
authoritative, and a receiver MUST adopt in-band metadata when it
differs from the catalog's initialization data.  Catalog content is
untrusted input; a receiver MUST validate that the decoded <tt>data</tt> is
a well-formed <tt>ftyp</tt> + <tt>moov</tt> sequence before passing it to a
decoder, and MUST discard it otherwise.</t>
<t>Some implementations carry the same bytes in a per-track string
field, <tt>initData</tt>, which <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> does not define.  A
receiver MAY accept <tt>initData</tt> on an mmtp track and validates it in
the same way.  When a track carries both <tt>initRef</tt> and <tt>initData</tt>, the
receiver uses <tt>initRef</tt>.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="object-identifier-assignment-and-reconstruction"><name>Object Identifier Assignment and Reconstruction</name>
<t>The publisher numbers the objects of each group in source order, as
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 6.2 requires.  The first object of the
group has Object ID 0.  It is the AL-FEC signaling object when the
group carries one (Section 8), and the FT=0 object otherwise.  Each
later object, in whichever subgroup, has the Object ID of the object
before it plus one.  An Object ID therefore identifies one object of
its group, as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 2.1 requires, and
the Subgroup ID still identifies the data unit (Section 4.3).  The
packetizer emits each data unit's packets contiguously
(Section 5.2.2), and Subgroup IDs follow source order
(Section 5.3.2), so ascending Object ID order within a group is also
ascending Subgroup ID order.  A FETCH or fill fetch stream, which
sends a group's objects in Object ID order
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.2.1), therefore delivers them
in the order that Section 4.3 requires.</t>
<t>MoQ Transport carries Object IDs as deltas on the wire
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Sections 11.3.1 and 11.4.1.1), and the
objects of every subgroup other than Subgroup 0 have Object IDs
greater than zero.  A receiver MUST reconstruct each object's
absolute Object ID from that encoding.  It MUST NOT assume that a
subgroup's first Object ID is zero, that successive objects differ by
a fixed step, or that an absolute Object ID is carried explicitly.</t>
<t>Object IDs identify preserved source objects
within a group; they do not replace the MMTP packet sequence, FI
countdown, or active-data-unit association required by Sections 5.2
and 5.3.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="media-fragment-unit-mfu-mode"><name>Media Fragment Unit (MFU) Mode</name>
<t>This timed-media profile transports each authored MPU data unit without
rewriting it:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[MFU Mode (one subgroup per MPU data unit):
  Group N:
   [SG 0 / Obj 0: [MMTP type=0x02 id=0][SH][AL-FEC msg]] (Section 8)
    SG 0 / Obj s:   [MMTP][PH FT=0 FI=0][ftyp+mmpu+moov]
    SG 1 / Obj s+1: [MMTP][PH FT=1 FI=0][moof+mdat prefix]
    SG 2 / Obj s+2: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=0][DU][sample 1]
    SG 3 / Obj s+3: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=0][DU][sample 2]
  ...

Fragmented FT=2 sample (Section 5.2):
  Group N, SG 2:
    Obj s+2: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=1][DU][sample part 1]
    Obj s+3: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=2][sample part 2]
    Obj s+4: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=3][sample part 3]

Subsample-partitioned FT=2 sample (Section 5.2.1): one sample,
two producer-authored subsample data units:
  Group N:
    SG 4 / Obj a..b:   [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=1][DU offset=0]  ... FI=3
    SG 5 / Obj b+1..c: [MMTP][PH FT=2 FI=1][DU offset=L0] ... FI=3

[MMTP] = MMTP packet header (Section 3.1): 12 bytes, since C = 0,
         plus a header extension when X = 1.
[PH]   = MPU-mode payload header, which carries the Fragmentation
         Indicator (FI); the FI is not in the MMTP packet header.
[SH]   = signaling message payload header (Section 3.1).
[...]  = OPTIONAL signaling object.  When present it is Object 0,
         the first object of SG 0, and FT=0 is the object after it.
s      = 1 when the signaling object is present, 0 when it is
         absent.  Object IDs count the group's objects in source
         order across subgroups (Section 4.6).
]]></artwork>
<t>For conformance, an <tt>mmtp</tt> track in this document carries timed media
only.  ISO/IEC 23008-1 Clause 9.3.2.3 defines the Timed Flag as
indicating whether the MPU is timed or non-timed, independently of the
FT value.  Every MPU-mode packet with FT=0, FT=1, or FT=2 in this
profile MUST carry <tt>T = 1</tt>; a packet with <tt>T = 0</tt> MUST be rejected.
Checking only FT=2 would leave metadata packets unchecked.  The ISO
non-timed DU identity and four-byte header remain outside this profile;
no <tt>Item_ID</tt>-based mapping is defined here.</t>
<t>FT=0 initializes the track, FT=1 supplies the authoritative movie
fragment structure and sample table, and FT=2 supplies the exact bytes
of each sample.  That order is a decoder contract, not a hint.</t>

<section anchor="authored-movie-fragment-timing"><name>Authored Movie-Fragment Timing</name>
<t>For timed media, receivers MUST derive sample timing and layout only
from the authored ISOBMFF metadata carried by FT=0 and FT=1:</t>

<ol spacing="compact">
<li>FT=0 supplies the one media track's <tt>mdhd</tt> timescale and <tt>trex</tt>
defaults.  It MUST contain a usable <tt>mvex</tt>/<tt>trex</tt> for that track.</li>
<li>FT=1 begins with a byte-for-byte copy of the authored <tt>moof</tt> and
carries a byte-for-byte copy of the original <tt>mdat</tt> prefix through
the byte before the first media sample.  This includes the original
<tt>mdat</tt> header and any auxiliary sample information.  The
<tt>mfhd.sequence_number</tt> identifies the movie fragment referenced by
subsequent timed-MFU DU headers.</li>
<li>For the <tt>traf</tt> whose <tt>tfhd.track_ID</tt> matches the independent media
track's <tt>tkhd.track_ID</tt>, <tt>tfdt</tt> supplies the first decode time.
Each sample duration and size is resolved using the ISOBMFF
precedence rules across <tt>trun</tt>, <tt>tfhd</tt>, and <tt>trex</tt>; composition time
is decode time plus the authored <tt>trun</tt> composition-time offset.
Signed offsets MUST remain signed.  Sample byte positions are
resolved from the authored base-data-offset and <tt>trun.data_offset</tt>
rules, not from a fixed <tt>mdat</tt>-header guess.</li>
<li>Each FT=2 timed DU identifies one sample -- or one producer-authored
subsample of it -- by <tt>(MPU_sequence_number,
movie_fragment_sequence_number, sample_number, offset)</tt>.  A
whole-sample data unit carries <tt>offset</tt> zero; a subsample data unit
(Section 5.2.1) carries the authored byte position of its first
media byte within the sample.  Section 5.3.3 defines sample
completion.</li>
</ol>
<t>A receiver MUST reject a missing or ambiguous media track, timescale,
movie-fragment sequence, <tt>tfdt</tt>, or sample identity.  It MUST also
reject any sample duration, sample size, byte position, or composition
offset that remains unresolved or invalid after applying all authored
<tt>trun</tt>, <tt>tfhd</tt>, <tt>trex</tt>, and implicit ISOBMFF rules.  An absent
per-sample <tt>trun</tt> composition-time-offset resolves to zero, and an
absent <tt>trun.data_offset</tt> is not by itself an error when the ISOBMFF
base-data-offset and run-continuation rules resolve the byte position.
The receiver MUST reject overlapping sample byte ranges, undeclared
bytes, duplicate samples, duplicate or overlapping subsample data
units (Section 5.2.1), and FT=2 media for which the governing FT=0
or FT=1 has not been accepted.  It MUST NOT synthesize timing from the
MMTP Timestamp, packet or MPU counters, MoQ Object IDs, arrival time,
catalog cadence, codec frame-rate guesses, or previously observed
samples.</t>
<t>The MMTP Timestamp is a send time, not media time (Section 3.1).
Any absolute MMT presentation anchor and edit-list offset are applied
as specified by PI/MPU presentation signalling and ISOBMFF; a receiver
without the required anchor MUST reject that timeline rather than
silently omit the authored adjustment.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="fragmentation-and-strict-active-du-reassembly"><name>Fragmentation and Strict Active-DU Reassembly</name>
<t>A single MFU can exceed the path MTU, but the ISO MPU-mode payload
header does not permit an unbounded number of fragments.  The 8-bit
<tt>fragment_counter</tt> is the number of MMTP payloads containing fragments
of the same data unit that succeed the current payload; it is not a
modulo sequence number.  A complete FI=0 data unit MUST carry zero.
For a fragmented data unit carried in N payloads, where 2 &lt;= N &lt;= 256,
the FI=1 payload MUST carry N - 1, every succeeding payload MUST
decrement the value by one, and the FI=3 payload MUST carry zero.  The
counter MUST NOT wrap or repeat within a data unit.</t>
<t>The mfu mapping defined here carries exactly one data unit per MMTP
payload, so <tt>aggregation_flag</tt> MUST be zero.  The upstream MMTP
packetizer produces conformant data units, and an input MMTP flow used
by this mapping MUST already satisfy the 256-payload bound for every
data unit.  In this profile an FT=2 timed data unit carries one whole
sample, or exactly one producer-authored subsample of it
(Section 5.2.1).  A sample whose media exceeds one data unit's
capacity MUST be partitioned into subsample data units by the origin
packetizer per Section 5.2.1, before this mapping applies -- never by
a relay and never by this mapping, which does not repacketize or
subdivide an input data unit.  Such a sample MUST NOT be carried by
wrapping or extending the counter, silently truncated, or split into a
second MPU, and an access unit MUST NOT be split across multiple MPUs
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Section 6.4).  A publisher MUST reject a purported
data unit that exceeds the bound, has an invalid countdown, or uses
aggregation.  It MUST NOT wrap or extend the counter, divide one data
unit's overflow between subgroups, or synthesize MoQ Object IDs to
make a non-conformant MMTP data unit appear valid.</t>
<t>Each MMTP packet maps to exactly one MoQ object, and the publisher
MUST NOT reassemble MFU fragments:</t>

<ol spacing="compact">
<li>The publisher MUST publish each MMTP packet of a data unit as a
separate object within that data unit's subgroup (Section 4.3), preserving the
MMTP packet header and the MPU-mode payload header.  Those headers
carry the Fragmentation Indicator
and MPU sequence number.  Object IDs identify the preserved source
packets within the group (Section 4.6) but are not MFU identities
or media timestamps.</li>
<li>The publisher MUST NOT reassemble or reorder fragments based on
the Fragmentation Indicator.  It routes each packet to (track,
group, subgroup) by packet_id, MPU boundary, data-unit type, and the
strict active-DU state of Section 5.3: a change of MPU sequence
number starts the next group (Section 4.3), and each distinct data
unit within the group maps to its own subgroup as defined in
Section 5.3.</li>
<li><t>The receiver MUST reassemble each data unit from the objects of its
subgroup before media processing.  After restoring serial packet
order (Section 5.3.3), it applies the FI/counter state machine of
Section 5.3:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>A single object with FI=0 is a complete, unfragmented data unit;
for FT=2 that data unit is one MFU.</li>
<li>FT=2 objects with FI=1 (first), FI=2 (zero or more middle), and FI=3
(last) reassemble, in that restored MMTP order, into one MFU by
concatenating each fragment's media bytes, delimited as defined
below.</li>
<li>The receiver MUST validate the <tt>fragment_counter</tt> countdown with
the state machine of Section 5.3.2.  Any missing, repeated,
wrapped, or non-decrementing count invalidates the entire MFU.</li>
<li>The reassembled MFU's RAP flag is taken from its FI=1 (or FI=0)
object.</li>
</ul></li>
</ol>
<t>The bytes concatenated are each fragment's media (data unit)
   bytes only -- not everything after the MMTP packet header.  Every
   fragment begins with a 12-or-more-byte MMTP packet header.  The
   receiver MUST parse the C and X flags, packet-counter presence, and
   header-extension length to locate the following 8-byte MPU-mode
   payload header; it MUST NOT assume a fixed offset of 12 bytes.  The
   MPU-mode payload header contains, by <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
   Clause 9.3.2.3 name with this document's alias in parentheses,
   length (<tt>payload_length</tt>, 16), FT (<tt>fragment_type</tt>, 4), T
   (<tt>timed_flag</tt>, 1), f_i (<tt>fragmentation_indicator</tt>, 2),
   aggregation_flag (1), fragment_counter (8), and
   MPU_sequence_number (32); both headers are stripped from every
   fragment.</t>
<t>The 16-bit <tt>payload_length</tt> field MUST be encoded and interpreted
   as the number of bytes following that field within the MPU payload,
   as defined by <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>.  It therefore includes the remaining
   six bytes of the 8-byte MPU-mode payload header.  For FT=2 packets,
   the declared lengths are:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[   FI=0 or FI=1: payload_length = 6 + DU_header_octets + media_octets
   FI=2 or FI=3: payload_length = 6 + media_octets
]]></artwork>
<t><tt>DU_header_octets</tt> is 14 for timed media and 4 for non-timed media,
   and the right-hand side MUST NOT exceed the 16-bit maximum of 65535.
   A trailing Source FEC Payload ID is outside the declared MPU payload
   and MUST NOT be counted.  A publisher MUST NOT encode a media-only or
   DU-plus-media length convention.  A receiver MUST require the
   declared MPU payload to end exactly at the protected MPU boundary
   before the Source FEC Payload ID, when present.  It MUST reject a
   declaration that is too short, cannot contain the required header
   bytes, extends beyond the available MPU payload bytes, leaves
   undeclared bytes before the outer trailer, or consumes that trailer.</t>
<t>The DU header (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Figures 12 and 13: 14 bytes for
   timed media -- movie_fragment_sequence_number (32),
   sample_number (32), offset (32), priority (8),
   dep_counter (8) -- or 4 bytes for non-timed media) follows the
   payload header on an FI=0 object and on the FI=1 first fragment;
   it is likewise stripped rather than concatenated into the media
   stream.  When the packet's FEC Type is 1, the trailing 4-byte
   Source FEC Payload ID (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 8.5) is excluded as
   well.
4. FT=0 and FT=1 MUST each be unaggregated, complete FI=0 data units
   with <tt>fragment_counter</tt> zero.  Their payload length is six plus the
   metadata octets; they have no DU header.  Fragmented or empty
   metadata is rejected by this profile.
5. The receiver MUST bound both in-flight data-unit memory and pending
   FT=1 sample records.  At either bound it MUST reclaim a slot by
   evicting the least recently admitted incomplete record (an open
   data unit or a parked continuation run) and admit the new one; it
   rejects only when no such record exists.  A record that has
   already completed is never a candidate.  An incomplete data
   unit is discarded on declared discontinuity or unrecoverable loss
   and is never emitted.</t>
<t>For very large frames where FEC cannot recover the loss, receivers
SHOULD support resolution-tier fallback (subscribe to a lower-resolution
track of the switching set and upscale) rather than stalling.</t>

<section anchor="subsample-data-units"><name>Subsample Data Units</name>
<t>At a given packet size, one data unit carries at most 256 MMTP
payloads of media.  A single intra-coded 4K or 8K sample routinely
exceeds that capacity.  This section defines the only conformant way
to carry such a sample: the origin packetizer partitions it into
subsample data units, using the <tt>offset</tt> field that <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Section 9.3.2.3 already defines in the timed-MFU DU header.  The
partition is producer-authored and wire-stated; nothing about it is
inferred.</t>
<t>A subsample data unit is an ordinary FT=2 timed data unit: it has its
own DU header, its own FI chain, and its own <tt>fragment_counter</tt>
countdown bounded by 256 payloads (Section 5.2).  Its identity is
<tt>(packet_id, MPU_sequence_number, movie_fragment_sequence_number,
sample_number, offset)</tt>, where <tt>offset</tt> is the authored byte position
of the data unit's first media byte within the sample.</t>
<t>Origin packetizer requirements:</t>

<ol spacing="compact">
<li>A packetizer MUST emit a sample as a single whole-sample data unit
(<tt>offset</tt> zero) whenever the sample fits within one data unit's
capacity.  Subsample partitioning of a sample that fits is not
conformant.</li>
<li>When partitioning, the first subsample data unit MUST carry
<tt>offset</tt> zero and each subsequent one MUST carry an <tt>offset</tt> equal
to the sum of the media lengths of all preceding subsample data
units of that sample: offsets are strictly increasing, with no gap
and no overlap.</li>
<li>Each subsample data unit of one sample MUST be published as its
own subgroup per Section 5.3.2, contiguously per Section 5.2.2.</li>
<li><tt>priority</tt> and <tt>dep_counter</tt> describe the sample and SHOULD be
identical across its subsample data units.</li>
</ol>
<t>Relays and this mapping MUST NOT create, merge, or re-partition
subsample data units.</t>
<t>Receiver sample assembly: a subsample-partitioned sample completes
only when every one of its subsample data units has completed under
the state machine of Section 5.3.2 and, ordered by <tt>offset</tt>, the data
units begin at zero, are byte-adjacent (each <tt>offset</tt> equals the
preceding <tt>offset</tt> plus the preceding data unit's media length), and
their total media length equals the sample's authored size from the
FT=1 record.  A gap, overlap, duplicate <tt>offset</tt>, or length mismatch
invalidates the sample; the receiver MUST NOT emit a partial sample or
synthesize missing bytes.  Completion is a protocol event -- every
constituent subgroup complete -- and on reliable transport a receiver
MUST NOT substitute timers, cadence, buffer occupancy, or successor
arrival for it.  On lossy paths each subsample data unit completes,
possibly after FEC recovery (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 9), or is discarded
as incomplete (Section 5.2, item 5), like any other data unit; no
additional sample-level timer is defined or permitted.</t>
<t>The sample's RAP flag is the RAP flag of the FI=0 or FI=1 object of
its offset-0 data unit.  FEC is unaffected by the partition: source
symbols are MMTP packets (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>), and the packet stream's block
and interleave structure does not depend on data-unit boundaries.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="source-contiguity"><name>Source Contiguity</name>
<t><xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> does not prohibit a packetizer from emitting an
unrelated payload of the same <tt>packet_id</tt> between two fragments of one
data unit.  This profile does prohibit it.</t>
<t>An origin packetizer MUST emit every multi-packet unit on consecutive
<tt>packet_sequence_number</tt> values of its <tt>packet_id</tt>, in authored order,
with no other payload of that <tt>packet_id</tt> between its packets: the
fragments of a data unit in FI order, and the subsample data units of
one sample (Section 5.2.1) in ascending <tt>offset</tt> order.  The sequence
numbers of the FI=1 fragment, of each FI=2 fragment, and of the FI=3
fragment MUST be successive values under
modulo-2^32 arithmetic.  A data unit of a different <tt>packet_id</tt> MAY be
emitted at any point, and a further data unit of the same <tt>packet_id</tt>
MAY be emitted once that data unit's FI=3 fragment has been emitted,
subject to the sample-level contiguity above.</t>
<t>The requirement constrains the packetizer's emission order only.  Loss
or reordering on the path does not violate it: the receiver restores
serial packet order before reassembly (Section 5.3.3).  Repair
carried on its own flow bears a different <tt>packet_id</tt> and therefore
cannot interleave.</t>
<t>A violating data unit never completes at the receiver, which
associates continuations only through active data-unit state
(Section 5.3) and evicts the stranded records without a protocol
error (Section 5.2, item 5).  A receiver MUST NOT relax association to
tolerate such a producer: a continuation admitted into the wrong data
unit corrupts media that would otherwise have been discarded.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="active-data-unit-association-and-subgroup-derivation"><name>Active Data-Unit Association and Subgroup Derivation</name>
<t>Object IDs are transport coordinates, not an MMTP continuation key.
A fragment recovered below the MoQ object layer has no Object ID, and
Object IDs from two delivery paths are not comparable.  The MMTP DU
header is also not a per-fragment coordinate: this profile carries it
only in the FI=0 or FI=1 payload (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.3.2 does
not specify whether FI=2 and FI=3 fragments repeat it).  FI=2 and FI=3
continuations carry media bytes but no movie-fragment sequence, sample
number, or sample offset.</t>
<t>Consequently a receiver MUST associate continuations through the
ordered, bounded active-data-unit state defined here.  It MUST NOT use
an MMTP Timestamp, MoQ Object ID, signaling identifier, packet arrival
time or order, inferred byte offset, recently completed identity, or a
(stream, MPU sequence number) pair or fragment counter alone as a
fallback association.</t>

<section anchor="first-fragment-identity"><name>First-Fragment Identity</name>
<t>For an FT=2 first or complete fragment, <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> defines a
transport-independent data-unit identity in the DU header:</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Object class</th>
<th>Data-unit identity</th>
<th><xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref></th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td>Timed-media MFU</td>
<td>packet_id, MPU_sequence_number, movie_fragment_sequence_number, sample_number, offset</td>
<td>Section 9.3.2.3</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>Non-timed media MFU</td>
<td>packet_id, MPU_sequence_number, Item_ID</td>
<td>Section 9.3.2.3</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t>For this timed-media profile, <tt>offset</tt> MUST be zero for a whole-sample
data unit and MUST equal the authored subsample byte position for a
subsample data unit (Section 5.2.1);
<tt>movie_fragment_sequence_number</tt> and <tt>sample_number</tt> MUST be non-zero,
and <tt>MPU_sequence_number</tt> MAY be zero (indeed, ISO/IEC 23008-1 requires
zero for the first MPU in an Asset).  The <tt>packet_id</tt> MUST be
non-zero: packet_id 0 is the MMTP signaling flow (Section 3.1) and
carries no media data unit, so a receiver MUST reject an MPU-mode
packet (packet type 0x00) on packet_id 0 rather than admit it to
active state.  A non-zero <tt>packet_id</tt> is validated in the scope of its
MMTP session; on multicast delivery it is validated against the
<tt>packetId</tt> values the endpoint advertises (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref>
Section 5).  A continuation inherits the accepted first-fragment
identity from active state; it does not reconstruct or guess another
copy of the DU header.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="subgroup-derivation"><name>Subgroup Derivation</name>
<t>Section 4.3 assigns Subgroup 0 to FT=0.  The publisher assigns every
following FT=1 or FT=2 data unit the next unused Subgroup ID in source
order.  All packets from one FI=1 through FI=3 chain share that ID.
An FI=2 or FI=3 packet therefore remains in the subgroup opened by the
immediately preceding FI=1 packet on the same <tt>packet_id</tt>; a new data
unit MUST NOT interleave before the chain closes (Section 5.2.2).</t>
<t>The publisher and receiver each maintain at most one active fragmented
data unit per <tt>(packet_id, MPU_sequence_number)</tt> while processing
subgroups in order:</t>

<ol spacing="compact">
<li>FI=0 requires <tt>fragment_counter == 0</tt> and no active data unit.  For
FT=2 it requires a valid DU header and represents the complete
sample.  FT=0 and FT=1 are permitted only in this form.</li>
<li>FI=1 requires no active data unit, a counter <tt>c</tt> in 1..255, and, for
FT=2, a valid DU header.  It creates active state containing the
data-unit type, timed flag, full first-fragment identity, destination
subgroup, and <tt>next_expected_counter = c - 1</tt>.</li>
<li>FI=2 requires exactly one matching active state and a non-zero
counter equal to the next expected counter.  It appends only the
declared media bytes and decrements the expected counter.</li>
<li>FI=3 requires exactly one matching active state,
<tt>next_expected_counter == 0</tt>, and a wire counter of zero.  It appends
the declared media bytes, closes the state, and emits the complete
data unit only after all size and authored-timing checks succeed.</li>
</ol>
<t>An FI=0 or FI=1 while state is active is an overlap.  An FI=2 or FI=3
without it is an orphan.  A changed packet ID, MPU sequence, FT, timed
flag, subgroup, skipped/repeated counter, FI=2 at zero, or FI=3 before
the expected counter reaches zero is a mismatch or gap.  The receiver
MUST reject all of these and MUST NOT advance, replace, or consume valid state or pending sample
timing on rejection.  A new MPU arriving while the prior MPU has an
incomplete data unit declares loss and discontinuity; the incomplete
unit is discarded and never emitted.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="receiver-admission-and-completion"><name>Receiver Admission and Completion</name>
<t>A receiver admits a fragment only after its declared MPU payload
boundary, outer FEC trailer, stream scope, subgroup order, and active-DU
transition all validate.  Duplicate packets may be dropped by exact
MMTP packet identity before admission, but a duplicate MUST NOT create
or advance active state.  Multi-path combining and FEC recovery MUST
restore the same per-<tt>packet_id</tt> serial packet order before this state
machine, using modulo-2^32 serial-number arithmetic across
<tt>packet_sequence_number</tt> wrap within a bounded replay window.  The
MMTP-session and MoQ-track scope are part of that ordering state;
neither mechanism may fabricate a missing transition.</t>
<t>Completion is transactional.  For a whole-sample data unit the
receiver first validates the full FI chain and the matching unconsumed
FT=1 sample record; the reassembled FT=2 media length MUST equal that
sample's authored size.  For a subsample-partitioned sample it
additionally requires every constituent subsample data unit to have
completed, with the byte-adjacency and total-length checks of
Section 5.2.1.  Only then may it emit the sample and consume that
record.  Every <tt>(sample, offset)</tt> data unit is admitted at most once,
and every described sample is emitted at most once.  A failed check leaves every pre-existing valid state and timing record
unchanged, except that an explicitly declared discontinuity discards
the incomplete prior unit.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="random-access-and-priority"><name>Random Access and Priority</name>
<t>An MPU begins at a Stream Access Point: the first access unit of an
MPU is a random access point (RAP) (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Section 6.4;
Section 4.3).  Accordingly a receiver:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>SHOULD gate the start of media decoding on the availability of a
complete RAP MFU, including a RAP MFU completed by FEC recovery;
and</li>
<li>SHOULD prioritize FEC recovery and retention of fragments whose
DU header carries a higher priority or dep_counter value
(Section 5.2; the subsample_priority and dependency_counter of
<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Section 9.3.2.3), since these are decode-order
roots upon which other access units depend.</li>
</ul>
<t>On a multicast or Automatic Multicast Tunneling (AMT) leg,
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 11.4 specifies the receiver repair policy this
implies.</t>
</section>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="subscriber-join-and-relay-behavior"><name>Subscriber Join and Relay Behavior</name>
<t>This section defines the join procedure for subscribers.  A
subscriber reaches its first decodable frame without waiting for the
next group boundary by joining at the start of the current group
with the fill mechanism of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.5.
The join needs no relay behavior beyond <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref>,
and relays never parse MMTP (Section 6.2).</t>

<section anchor="subscriber-join-procedure"><name>Subscriber Join Procedure</name>
<t>A subscriber joins a live mmtp-packaged track as follows:</t>

<ol>
<li><t><strong>Catalog.</strong> Subscribe to the catalog track (the track named
<tt>catalog</tt>, Section 12) as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5 requires,
joining at the start of its current group
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.5), and validate the
catalog.  Validation includes the per-track REQUIRED fields of
Section 12.1.  A subscriber MUST NOT issue SUBSCRIBE for a track
whose catalog entry fails validation.  It also applies the
switching-set agreement check of Section 4.4.2 and handles a
disagreement as that section specifies.</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>Decoder initialization.</strong> If the catalog provides
initialization data for the track (Section 4.5) and that data
validates, initialize the decoder from it immediately.  In all
cases the subscriber MUST accept the
authoritative FT=0 object in Subgroup 0 before admitting this
group's FT=1 or FT=2 data units.  An AL-FEC signaling object that
precedes FT=0 in Subgroup 0 (Section 8) is not decoder
initialization and does not satisfy this step.</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>Subscribe at a group boundary.</strong> Join at the start of the
current group, as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.5
describes.  Send SUBSCRIBE with a LOCATION_FILTER of type 0x05
(Next Object) and a FILL_PARAMETERS parameter whose
LOCATION_FILTER has type 0x01 (Relative Start) and StartGroup = 1
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Sections 3.4, 9.20.9, and 9.20.15).
The publisher sends the current group, from its start up to the
Largest Object, on a fill fetch stream, and every later object on
the subscription, so each object arrives once.  The group start
carries FT=0 initialization (Subgroup 0), the FT=1 metadata
governing the first samples, and the RAP-bearing first FT=2
subgroup (Section 4.3); a subscription that starts mid-group
without a fill yields objects that cannot be decoded until the
next group.  A data unit that was still open at the join arrives
partly on the fill fetch stream and partly on its subgroup stream,
and the receiver combines the two before reassembly (Section 5.2).
If the fill fails or leaves a gap, the subscriber waits for the
next group, which the subscription delivers from its start.  A
subscriber that does not want the current group sends SUBSCRIBE
with a LOCATION_FILTER of type 0x01 and StartGroup = 0 instead.  A
NEW_GROUP_REQUEST (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 9.20.19)
cannot shorten that wait (Section 4.4.1).</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>Repair track.</strong> If the subscriber wants FEC protection and the
catalog signals FEC for the track, it SHOULD subscribe to the
repair track (Section 8.2) at the same time as the source track,
so that the first FEC block spanning the join point is
repairable.  Repair-track subscription is selective and optional
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.2).</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>Presentation gate.</strong> A subscriber MUST NOT submit media to the
decoder until it has (a) accepted the authoritative FT=0 and FT=1
data units and (b) a completely reassembled FT=2 sample whose RAP
flag is set (Section 5.2).  Objects received before that point are buffered
or discarded according to the receiver's reassembly bounds.</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>Loss and discontinuity.</strong> If a RAP MFU is discarded under
unrepairable loss (Section 5.2), the subscriber MUST
treat the track as discontinuous and MUST NOT resume presentation
before the next completely reassembled RAP MFU (normally the
start of the next group).  The same holds when the group's FT=0
data unit, or the FT=1 data unit governing its RAP, is lost, since
the RAP then cannot be admitted (Section 4.3).  On a multicast or
AMT leg, loss that spares those three data units does not make the
track discontinuous; <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 11.4 specifies its
handling.</t>
</li>
</ol>
</section>

<section anchor="relay-retention-for-late-joiners"><name>Relay Retention for Late Joiners</name>
<t>This section is informative.  A relay serves the fill fetch stream of
Section 6.1 from its cache, and fetches from upstream the objects it
does not hold (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Sections 3.2.3 and 3.4).  A
relay that caches the current group of each track it serves can
therefore start a late joiner without an upstream round trip.  The
join needs no mmtp-specific relay behavior.  A fill fetch stream
sends a group's objects in Object ID order, which is source order on
an mmtp track (Section 4.6), so it delivers Subgroup 0 and each
metadata subgroup before the FT=2 subgroups that depend on them, and
the relay does not parse MMTP.</t>
<t>Retention of groups older than the current group (for example to
serve FETCH-based catch-up) is permitted but out of scope for this
document.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="fec-integration"><name>FEC Integration</name>
<t>MMT's AL-FEC framework supports multiple FEC schemes, with the MMT
FEC codes specified in <xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> and parameters signaled via
MMTP signaling messages (Section 8.3); neither the framework nor
ATSC 3.0, which uses it for MMTP sessions (<xref target="ATSC-A331"></xref>
Section 8.1.2.5), requires a particular code, so the codes are
specified by <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>: &quot;reed-solomon&quot;, the Reed-Solomon code of
<xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> Clause 6, is the mandatory-to-implement scheme, and
RaptorQ <xref target="RFC6330"></xref> is OPTIONAL (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 4.3).  FEC
repair uses the model defined in <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[Source Track: video
  +-- Objects: MMTP packets with FEC Type=0 or 1 (source)

Repair Track: video/repair
  +-- Objects: MMTP packets with FEC Type=2 (repair)
]]></artwork>

<section anchor="interleaving"><name>Interleaving</name>
<t>Interleaving and typical interleave windows (<tt>interleaveDepthMs</tt>)
follow <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 9.  A positive <tt>interleaveDepthMs</tt> is the
elapsed source/repair send-span bound for each actual FEC block; it does not
select FEC block boundaries, derive a number of groups per block, or
require a fixed relationship between an FEC block and a media Group.
Absent and zero values follow <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.1 and do not supply
an elapsed-time deadline.  A typical window for ARIB STD-B60 content is
2000 ms.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="oti-signaling"><name>OTI Signaling</name>
<t>MoQ carries no RaptorQ Object Transmission Information (OTI,
<xref target="RFC6330"></xref> Section 3.3) in-session: receivers derive it per block
from the catalog <tt>fec</tt> fields and the block's SSB_length per
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 4.2.  The AL-FEC message of an MMTP session
(Section 8.3) carries none either (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3).</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="fec-parameter-signaling"><name>FEC Parameter Signaling</name>
<t>FEC parameters for mmtp-packaged tracks are signaled in the catalog
<tt>fec</tt> object, defined normatively in <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5, which is
authoritative for MoQ receivers (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.2).  A MoQ
receiver requires no in-session FEC signaling: the catalog carries
every FEC parameter it needs.
This document does not redefine the catalog fields but specifies
MMT-specific considerations for their use.</t>
<t>A publisher MAY also carry the MMTP AL-FEC signaling message of
Section 8.3 on a MoQ mmtp source track, as an object whose payload
is an MMTP signaling packet on packet_id 0 (Section 3.1).  When
present, it is published in Subgroup 0 of an MPU group as the object
immediately before, and in the same subgroup as, that group's FT=0
object, and a group carries at most one such object (Sections 4.2
and 4.3).  On a MoQ
track such an object is a redundant in-band copy of catalog state:
the message MUST NOT signal FEC parameters that contradict the
track's catalog <tt>fec</tt> object, and where the two disagree the catalog
governs.  The object carries no media data
unit and no repair symbol, so a MoQ receiver MUST NOT deliver it to
a media or repair decoder (Section 3.1); a receiver that does not
process MMTP signaling discards it.</t>
<t>The signaling object is not an FEC source symbol.  Its MMTP packet
has FEC Type 0 and no Source FEC Payload ID; it is not protected by
any repair symbol, is not counted in any FEC block or in
<tt>sourceSymbols</tt> (K), and has no SS_ID and no Encoding Symbol ID.
Because it occupies an Object ID (Object ID 0 of its group,
Section 4.6), Object IDs on an mmtp source track are not positions
in the FEC block: a receiver MUST take
each source symbol's SS_ID from the Source FEC Payload ID that trails
its FEC Type 1 packet (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 8.5), never from its
Object ID, and places the symbol in its block by that SS_ID
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 8.3).</t>
<t>A MoQ track carries only the
signaling packets its publisher chose to place on that track, so
the packet_sequence_number values it exhibits on packet_id 0 need
not be contiguous.  A receiver MUST NOT infer loss from a
packet_sequence_number gap on packet_id 0 of a MoQ track, and MUST
NOT defer any packet, including a later packet on packet_id 0,
behind such a gap.</t>

<section anchor="mmt-specific-fec-parameters"><name>MMT-Specific FEC Parameters</name>
<t>When used with MMT packaging, the catalog <tt>fec</tt> fields map as
follows:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li><strong>algorithm</strong>: the value whose code point the MMTP AL-FEC message
carries in <tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt> (Section 8.3)</li>
<li><strong>blockProfile</strong>: &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.1), the
ISO 23008-1 Annex C block profile, for which an AL-FEC message
carries the coding byte 0x14 (Section 8.3); REQUIRED when
<tt>algorithm</tt> is not &quot;none&quot;</li>
<li><strong>sourceSymbols</strong>: The largest number of MMTP packets (source
symbols) that an FEC block may hold; each block holds SSB_length of
them (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.4).  On the MMT path the canonical FEC
source symbol is one whole MMTP packet, before its Source FEC
Payload ID, framed with its length (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3)</li>
<li><strong>interleaveDepthMs</strong>: When positive, the elapsed source/repair send
span bound of each actual FEC block, as defined by <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 5.1; that section also defines absent and zero values.  It is
independent of <tt>groupDurationMs</tt> and does not imply a block count or
block boundary from MoQ Groups.  When ingesting broadcast content,
use the ISO protection-window signaling or a known source/repair
send-span bound.  A source-frame count alone does not bound the
actual packet send span.</li>
</ul>
<t>See <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> for the complete catalog field definitions, the
algorithm registry, and the OTI derivation.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="repair-tracks"><name>Repair Tracks</name>
<t>A source track's repair tracks are the track its <tt>fec.repairTrack</tt>
names and the tracks that name it in <tt>depends</tt> (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 5.1.1); <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.1 gives their conventional
names.  Subscription to them follows <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.2, and
their priorities <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 10.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="fec-signaling-for-multicast-delivery"><name>FEC Signaling for Multicast Delivery</name>
<t>For SSM and Any-Source Multicast (ASM) delivery there is no
bidirectional signaling channel.  FEC parameters reach multicast
receivers via:</t>

<ol>
<li><t><strong>MoQ Catalog Extension</strong> (authoritative for MoQ receivers,
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.2): out-of-band delivery in the catalog
<tt>fec</tt> object (see the worked catalog of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 5.1.2).</t>
</li>
<li><t><strong>MMTP AL-FEC Signaling (message_id=0x0203)</strong>: in-band delivery
of the AL-FEC message of <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause C.6, with
Table C.3 as replaced by <xref target="ISO.23008-1.AMD1"></xref>,
for ISO/IEC 23008-1 receivers that consume the flow without the
catalog, such as native broadcast (ATSC 3.0, ARIB STD-B60)
receivers.  A publisher that sends this message MUST carry it in
an MMTP signaling packet (packet type 0x02) on packet_id 0, the
MMTP signaling flow, after the signaling message payload header of
<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 9.3.4.2 (Section 3.1); on
multicast delivery it shares the multicast group of the media it
describes, and on MoQ delivery it MAY be carried as an object of an
mmtp source track under the rules of Section 8.  No track is
advertised on packet_id 0
(<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.1), and a receiver does not deliver
these packets to a media or repair decoder (Section 3.1;
<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 5)</t>
</li>
</ol>
<t>Each FEC source flow has one FEC encoded flow (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Clause C.6.3), so the message describes a source track's flow as one
entry of the message's <tt>fec_flow_descriptor</tt> naming exactly one repair
flow,
the track's layer-0 repair track (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3).  For a
track whose <tt>fec.blockProfile</tt> is &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot;, that entry carries:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>a <tt>number_of_assets</tt> of 1, the one Asset it lists being the source
track's, the Asset whose packet_id is the track's: an FEC source
flow of <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> may carry the packets of several Assets
(its Clause C.1), where an FEC instance of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> protects one
source track (its Section 6.3);</li>
<li>the coding byte 0x14, that is <tt>fec_coding_structure</tt> 0001
(one-stage), <tt>ssbg_mode</tt> 01, <tt>ffsrpts_flag</tt> 0 and
<tt>fec_payload_id_mode</tt> 0 (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3);</li>
<li>as its <tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt>, the code point that
<xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> Table 1 assigns to the code that the track's
<tt>fec.algorithm</tt> names: 3, the &quot;6330 code&quot; (RaptorQ), for &quot;raptorq&quot;,
and 1, the Reed-Solomon code, for &quot;reed-solomon&quot;;</li>
<li>as its <tt>repair_flow_id</tt>, the packet_id of the layer-0 repair
packets.  <xref target="ISO.23008-1.AMD1"></xref> makes this field 16 bits in the
one-stage branch, where the 2023 edition of Table C.3 gives it 8
bits and so cannot name a repair packet_id above 255;</li>
<li>as its <tt>length_of_repair_symbol</tt>, the track's <tt>fec.symbolSize</tt>
(T), the byte length of every repair symbol and, under ssbg_mode1,
of every source symbol (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Sections 5.1, 7.1 and 7.3), and
as its <tt>num_of_repair_symbol_per_packet</tt> 1, the one repair symbol
each repair packet carries (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.1), a field whose
semantics <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause C.6.3 gives for ssbg_mode2 alone;</li>
<li>as its <tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt>, the track's <tt>fec.sourceSymbols</tt>:
like that field, it bounds each block's SSB_length and is not the
size of any particular block (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.4); and</li>
<li>as its <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt>, the RSB_length that every
repair packet of the track's FEC instance carries: the total
repair count over the published layers, which is the track's
<tt>fec.repairSymbols</tt> while layer 0 is the only published layer
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.2).  A publisher that appends a layer
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.9) raises that total and sends a new
version of the message carrying it only after the last repair
packet generated under the previous total, of whichever block: a
block's RSB_length is the total in force when its repair symbols
were generated (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.1), so every repair packet
sent after the new version carries a value no lower than the
field it names.  The path keeps no order between the message, on
<tt>packet_id</tt> 0, and the repair flow (Section 5.2.2), so a receiver
of both can take a packet generated under the previous total
after the new version; the blocks generated under the raised
total follow every block generated under the previous one in the
serial order of their SS_Start (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.5), as its
Section 6.3.9 requires of the publisher, which the conversion rule
of Section 12.2 relies on instead.</li>
</ul>
<t>A publisher MUST NOT describe a repair layer above layer 0, or a
keyframe overlay, in the message, whether in that entry or in an
entry of its own: the one-stage coding structure names one repair
flow per FEC encoded flow, the overlay protects a RAP subset that no
<tt>packet_id</tt> identifies, and only the catalog declares either
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Sections 6.3, 6.4 and 8.5.1).</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="multicast-integration"><name>Multicast Integration</name>
<t>MMT content can be delivered via IP multicast (SSM, AMT) and TreeDN
<xref target="RFC9706"></xref>.  Platform-specific delivery paths, the
multicast endpoint catalog extension, and TreeDN/AMT integration are
defined in <xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref>, and the multicast packet format in its
Section 5.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="arib-std-b60-compatibility"><name>ARIB STD-B60 Compatibility</name>
<t>ARIB STD-B60 <xref target="ARIB-B60"></xref> (Japan's MMT-based broadcasting standard)
uses the same ISO 23008-1 foundation as ATSC 3.0.  Publishers SHOULD
preserve the original FEC parameters when ingesting ARIB STD-B60
content.</t>

<section anchor="clock-reference"><name>Clock Reference</name>
<t>ARIB STD-B60 uses the MMTP Timestamp of Section 3.1: the UTC send
time of the packet in NTP short format.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="transport-hierarchy"><name>Transport Hierarchy</name>
<t>Clients SHOULD attempt transports in the preference order that
<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 3 defines for native and browser clients.
AL-FEC (Section 7) is the loss recovery on SSM/AMT paths, which have
no retransmission.</t>
</section>

<section anchor="catalog-signaling"><name>Catalog Signaling</name>
<t>The MoQ catalog indicates MMT packaging and multicast endpoints.</t>
<t>The catalog of this suite is an MSF catalog: the root object and
its fields (<tt>version</tt>, <tt>generatedAt</tt>, <tt>tracks</tt>, ...), the
requirement that parsers ignore fields they do not understand, and
the base per-track fields are those of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 5.  The catalog is delivered as a MoQ track whose
case-sensitive Track Name is <tt>catalog</tt> (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 5).  The documents of this suite extend the base in the
same manner as
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> extends it: this document adds the packaging
value <tt>mmtp</tt> and the mmtp track fields (Section 12.1), <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
adds the per-track <tt>fec</tt> object and the <tt>fec-repair</tt> packaging
value, and <xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> adds the root-level <tt>multicast</tt>
member.  Every catalog field this suite uses is defined either by
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> or locally by a document of this suite (with
<tt>cmaf</tt> tracks per <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref>); no field
is defined by any other catalog specification.</t>

<section anchor="packaging-value-and-track-fields"><name>Packaging Value and Track Fields</name>
<t>This document defines a single packaging value:</t>

<artwork><![CDATA[packaging: "mmtp"
]]></artwork>
<t>carried in the per-track <tt>packaging</tt> field of the catalog
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.4).  The value extends the
allowed packaging values of that specification in the same manner
as the <tt>cmaf</tt> value of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> Section 3.5.1; see
Section 14 for the registry request.  Object payloads of an
mmtp-packaged track are whole MMTP packets per Section 4.2.</t>
<t>Per-track catalog fields for mmtp packaging:</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Field</th>
<th>Status</th>
<th>Type</th>
<th>Description</th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td><tt>packaging</tt></td>
<td>REQUIRED</td>
<td>String</td>
<td>MUST be &quot;mmtp&quot;</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>mmtpMode</tt></td>
<td>REQUIRED</td>
<td>String</td>
<td>MUST be &quot;mfu&quot; (Section 5); defined by this document</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>timescale</tt></td>
<td>REQUIRED</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>Media timescale in Hz (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.21, profiled REQUIRED here; Section 4.4.2)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt></td>
<td>REQUIRED for synchronized audio/video tracks</td>
<td>Signed integer</td>
<td>Track timestamp corresponding to shared presentation time zero (Section 4.4.1); defined by this document</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>groupDurationMs</tt></td>
<td>Conditional</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>REQUIRED without the tick form; positive integer ms (Section 4.4.2); informational when ticks are present</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>groupDurationTicks</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>Positive exact group duration in track ticks; authoritative when present (Section 4.4.2); defined by this document</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>altGroup</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>Switching-set membership key (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.12, profiled in Section 4.4)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>keyframeIntervalMs</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>Keyframe/GOP cadence, integer ms; video only (Section 4.4.3); defined by this document</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>keyframeIntervalTicks</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>Number</td>
<td>Integer-tick override for the keyframe interval (Section 4.4.3); defined by this document</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>initRef</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>String</td>
<td><tt>id</tt> of the root <tt>initDataList</tt> entry, of type &quot;inline&quot;, that holds the base64 ftyp+moov init segment (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Sections 5.1.7 and 5.2.13, profiled in Section 4.5)</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td><tt>fec</tt></td>
<td>OPTIONAL</td>
<td>Object</td>
<td>AL-FEC parameters, defined in <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5 (Section 8)</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t>All other base track fields of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2
apply unchanged.  In particular <tt>name</tt> and the rendition
parameters -- <tt>codec</tt> (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.18; required
for media tracks per that section), <tt>framerate</tt>, <tt>width</tt>, <tt>height</tt>,
<tt>samplerate</tt>, <tt>channelConfig</tt>, <tt>bitrate</tt>, and <tt>lang</tt> -- are flat,
top-level fields of the track object.</t>
<t><tt>mmtpMode</tt> selects the object layout and MUST be &quot;mfu&quot;.  It delivers
one subgroup per FT=0, FT=1, or FT=2 data unit as defined in Sections
4.3 and 5.  A subscriber MUST reject a track whose
<tt>mmtpMode</tt> is absent or has any other value; the object layout cannot
be inferred safely from received objects.</t>
<t>Example, with the <tt>data</tt> value shortened:</t>

<sourcecode type="json"><![CDATA[{
  "version": "draft-01",
  "tracks": [{
    "name": "video",
    "packaging": "mmtp",
    "isLive": true,
    "mmtpMode": "mfu",
    "timescale": 90000,
    "presentationAnchorTicks": 0,
    "groupDurationMs": 1000,
    "codec": "avc1.640028",
    "width": 1920,
    "height": 1080,
    "framerate": 30,
    "bitrate": 6000000,
    "initRef": "video-init"
  }],
  "initDataList": [{
    "id": "video-init",
    "type": "inline",
    "data": "AAAAIGZ0eXBpc29t..."
  }]
}
]]></sourcecode>
</section>

<section anchor="mmtp-signaling-to-moq-catalog-conversion"><name>MMTP Signaling to MoQ Catalog Conversion</name>
<t>This section is informative: it documents how a converter that
ingests an MMTP broadcast service, an ATSC 3.0 MMTP session
(<xref target="ATSC-A331"></xref> Section 8.1.2.1) or an ARIB STD-B60 service, derives a
MoQ catalog from the MMT signaling, and imposes no interoperability
requirements on MoQ publishers or subscribers.  A converter's output
catalog is subject to the normative catalog requirements of
Section 12.1 like any other catalog.  The MP table gives the
location of each Asset (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.3.9) and the
AL-FEC message the FEC parameters of each protected flow
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Annex C.6; Section 8.3 gives the fields a MoQ
publisher sets, which a converter reads back).</t>
<t>The <tt>multicast</tt> field in the output uses the multicast endpoint
format of <xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.1.  Conversion rules:</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>each MMTP session the MP table locates by its source address,
destination address and destination port -&gt; one
<tt>multicast.endpoints[]</tt> entry (<tt>sourceAddress</tt>, <tt>groupAddress</tt>,
<tt>port</tt>), and the Assets it carries -&gt; that endpoint's <tt>tracks[]</tt></li>
<li>each Asset -&gt; a track whose <tt>packetId</tt> is the Asset's packet_id,
unique within the session (<xref target="ATSC-A331"></xref> Section 8.1.2.1.1) and
carried by every packet of the flow, so a converter cannot renumber
it.  <xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.1 requires each <tt>packetId</tt> value to
denote one sub-flow across all endpoints of a sending entity and
reserves 0 for the signaling flow, so a converter publishes
sessions whose packet_ids collide under different namespaces, and
never advertises a track on packet_id 0</li>
<li>the AL-FEC message's entry for a flow -&gt; the track's <tt>fec</tt> object:
<tt>algorithm</tt> from <tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt>, &quot;reed-solomon&quot; for
code point 1 and &quot;raptorq&quot; for 3, <tt>symbolSize</tt> (T) from
<tt>length_of_repair_symbol</tt>, <tt>sourceSymbols</tt> (K) from
<tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt>, <tt>repairSymbols</tt> (P) from
<tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt>, and a repair track, named in
<tt>fec.repairTrack</tt>, whose <tt>packetId</tt> is the packet_id that
<tt>repair_flow_id</tt> names (Section 8.3).  The converter accepts an
entry whose <tt>number_of_assets</tt> is 1, whose coding byte is 0x14 and
whose <tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt> is 1 or 3: a source flow of
several Assets (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause C.1) is one block sequence
over the packets of several packet_ids, which no FEC instance of
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> protects (its Section 6.3 protects one source track),
a flow under any other coding structure, <tt>ssbg_mode</tt>, FFSRP_TS or
FEC payload ID mode is not one that &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; describes
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3), a session whose message names any other
code is outside <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> until its registry lists that code (its
Section 12), and the conversion of such a flow fails.  The one
repair flow the
one-stage entry names is the track's layer 0, and
<tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> is its P while layer 0 is the only
published layer, as in a one-stage session of <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>,
whose one repair flow carries the block's whole repair count.
That field bounds the repair count of a block (<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Clause C.6.3: the maximum allowed number of repair symbols in a
repair symbol block) where &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; carries P as the
RSB_length of every repair packet (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.1), on
which every receiver holding the highest layer the converter lists
(below) fails closed when a packet of that layer, where it is
above 0, or of a block at or after (in the serial order of
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.5) one of which it has received a repair
packet carrying at least the value, carries less than the
O_i + P_i its catalog derives for that layer, the field itself
(its Section 6.3.9), so
the converter, which receives the flow's repair packets before it
lists the repair track (below), lists it only once it has received
a repair packet of the flow carrying an RSB_length of at least the
field of the version it holds, and fails the conversion of a flow
whose repair packets carry an RSB_length below that field on a
block at or after, in the serial order of their SS_Start
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.5), one of which it has received a repair
packet carrying at least the field: such a flow is not one
&quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; describes.  A block before that one whose repair
packets carry less was generated under the previous total, after
whose last repair packet a publisher that appends a layer sends
the raised field (Section 8.3) but which the path, keeping no
order between the message and the repair flow (Section 5.2.2),
can deliver after it; and a flow no block of which carries at
least the field is one the converter never lists.  Such a packet
of an earlier block, below the <tt>repairSymbols</tt> the catalog gives
layer 0 (below) where the layers the converter lists above 0 count
less than the appended one, fails a receiver of the catalog closed
on nothing: the clause of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.9 for a packet
of a layer's own track applies to layers above 0 alone, layer 0's
coordinates depending on no count, and its anchored clause, which
anchors a held layer on a block of which the receiver has received
a repair packet carrying at least that layer's O_i + P_i, for
layer 0 its <tt>repairSymbols</tt> (the field where the converter lists
none above 0), treats such a packet as the conforming packet it
is, every block generated under a total below a layer's O_i + P_i
preceding, in the serial order of its Section 7.5, every block
generated under one at or above it (its Section 6.3.9, which has
a publisher apply a raised total from a block onward in that order
and lower none), on the repair track the
converter publishes as on the session's own endpoint, which
carries the sender's packets and from which the converter
withholds nothing.
An RSB_length above the
field is the append case of the next sentence.  A
MoQ publisher that appended a layer (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.9)
sends the raised total in that field (Section 8.3) while the named
flow carries only the P_0 symbols of each block (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 6.3.2), and neither the message nor the MP table describes
the layers above, so the converter sets <tt>repairSymbols</tt> to
<tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> less the <tt>repairSymbols</tt> of every
layer above 0 that it lists, and lists a layer it learns from
provisioning only where provisioning places it, with every other
layer it lists, above every layer it does not list, the topmost
layers of the publisher's set: layer 0's <tt>repairSymbols</tt> is then
the publisher's total below the lowest layer it lists above 0 (the
whole field where it lists none) and each listed layer's O_i
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.2) is the publisher's, while listing a
layer above which lies one the converter does not list would give
it an O_i that is not the publisher's, which no check detects, and
an O_i + P_i that its own-track packets generated before the
append of the layer it does not list fall below (its Section
6.3.9).  One that lists none publishes the whole field, which
overstates layer 0's count, and the loss tolerance a receiver
derives from it, by the layers it does not list.  The converter
keeps the <tt>repairSymbols</tt> it first
published for a track, and those of every layer it has listed,
for as long as it publishes the track: a later version of the
message that raises <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> changes nothing in
its catalog by itself, since <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.9 forbids
changing the <tt>repairSymbols</tt> of a published layer while any
receiver may still be consuming the source track, and says that a
receiver reading the smaller bound excludes only symbols of layers
it has not joined.  A layer above 0 that the converter learns from
provisioning after it published the track, one that provisioning
places next above the highest layer the converter lists, the
publisher having appended it after the converter read the field
with no layer the converter has not learned below it, so that its
O_i, the total of every layer below it (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section
6.3.2), is the total the catalog derives for the highest layer
listed before it, layer 0's <tt>repairSymbols</tt> plus those of every
layer above 0 listed before it, and the field of the version it
holds has risen by at least that layer's <tt>repairSymbols</tt>, it
appends at the next index (its Section 6.3.9): its symbols' RS_IDs
run upward from that total, and its O_i + P_i is at most the
field, which every block generated under the raised total carries.
The field's rise alone places no layer, a field risen by more than
a layer's <tt>repairSymbols</tt> counting a layer the converter has not
learned, which can lie below the learned one.  A layer that
provisioning does not so place, or whose symbols the field the
converter first read already counted, it lists only by retiring
the source encoding and publishing the source track and its repair
tracks as a separate rendition that lists it, since appending it
would give it an O_i that is not the publisher's, which no check
detects, or an O_i + P_i above the wire RSB_length, on which every
receiver joining it fails closed (that section), while lowering
layer 0's <tt>repairSymbols</tt> to fit it is the change that section
forbids.  A
later version that lowers <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> below the
total its catalog derives for the highest layer it lists, layer
0's <tt>repairSymbols</tt> plus those of every layer above 0 it lists, is
a change that section lets no publisher make, on which a receiver
holding the highest layer it lists fails closed on the first
packet of that layer, where it is above 0, or of a block at or
after, in that serial order, one of which it has received a repair
packet carrying at least that total, whose RSB_length falls below
the O_i + P_i its catalog derives for that layer, which is that
total, and one that no such packet reaches, the check anchored on
no block it received or, holding that layer alone, reached by no
repair packet after the change, learns of the change only at the
next catalog refresh (that section), so the
converter
retires the source encoding and
publishes the source track and its repair tracks as a separate
rendition carrying the lowered value, as that section has a
publisher that must retire a layer do; a repair packet whose
RSB_length falls below that total once the track is published, on
a block at or after, in that serial order, one of which it has
received a repair packet carrying at least that total, is the same
violation and has the converter retire the source encoding in the
same way, the separate rendition listing the repair track as the
first listing did, once a repair packet of the flow received after
that one carries at least the field of the version it then holds,
as the violating packet, below the field of the version held when
it arrived, did not.  The
conversion
of a flow fails where the <tt>fec</tt> object it would yield fails a
catalog rule of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Sections 5.1 and 6.3.4, on which a
receiver fails closed: a <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> of 0 names no
repair flow a catalog can publish (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.1
requires a <tt>repairSymbols</tt> of at least 1 when a repair track is
published), a <tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt> of 0 names no block (a
<tt>sourceSymbols</tt> of at least 1), and a <tt>length_of_repair_symbol</tt>
below 14 names a symbol that protects no MMTP packet under the
T - 2 construction of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3, whose protected
packet begins with the 12-octet MMTP packet header of Section 3.1
(a <tt>symbolSize</tt> of at least 14 under &quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot;); an entry
that names code point 3 with a <tt>length_of_repair_symbol</tt> that is
not a multiple of 8 names a T no &quot;raptorq&quot; track can carry
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 4.2 fixes the Symbol Alignment at 8, which an
MMTP session, carrying no OTI, does not impose on its symbol
length), one with <tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt> above 56403 fails
rule 6 of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.4, and one with
<tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt> plus <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> above
2^24 names an ESI no instance can produce (rule 5, which bounds
K + totalP - 1 by 2^24 - 1, a sum the two 24-bit fields can
exceed); and an entry that names code point 1 with
<tt>maximum_k_for_repair_flow</tt> plus <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> above
255 names a block no &quot;reed-solomon&quot; instance can hold (rule 12,
which bounds K plus the repair count of every layer).  The
conversion also fails for a flow whose <tt>repair_flow_id</tt> is 0, the
signaling flow (Section 3.1), the flow's own packet_id, or the
packet_id of another track of the session, a value that
<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.1 requires to denote one sub-flow (a
repair flow carries a packet_id of its own, <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref>
Clause C.6.3), and for the flows of any two entries that name one
<tt>repair_flow_id</tt> or list one Asset: two source tracks naming one
repair track, or two <tt>fec</tt> objects for one track, are shapes no
FEC instance of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> has, a repair packet belonging to the
instance of the track it arrived on (its Section 6.4.1).  The
message names the repair flow
by packet_id without a location, and the MP table does not list it
(<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 5), so the converter lists the repair
track in the <tt>tracks[]</tt> of each endpoint on whose session it
receives packets of that packet_id, which is where a receiver
without the catalog finds them; a repair-only endpoint (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>
Section 6.3.6) is one the converter learns from provisioning, not
from the signaling</li>
<li><tt>fec.interleaveDepthMs</tt>, the ISO protection-window send span from
the first source or repair packet to the last: set only when the
AL-FEC message's <tt>protection_window_time</tt> or an independently known
source/repair send schedule supplies that span, as a positive
integer millisecond upper bound that covers the complete span,
never rounded down; when the span is unknown, or the message
signals zero (the size-based case), the converter omits it</li>
<li>a live service -&gt; <tt>isLive</tt> = true (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 5.2.7) on each media track and on its repair track, which
the converter publishes while it ingests the service</li>
<li>the source composition/edit-list origin for each synchronized media
track -&gt; <tt>presentationAnchorTicks</tt>; a converter preserves one
common presentation origin across audio and video, and does not
emit zero merely because the source offset was unavailable</li>
<li><tt>bitrate</tt> (<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.22) from whatever
signaling carries it, or from another source, or the conversion of
that track fails</li>
</ul>
<t>Flows sharing one (sourceAddress, groupAddress, port) tuple collapse
into a single endpoint whose <tt>tracks[]</tt> array lists them all.  MMT
signaling carries no <tt>networkSource</tt> (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.2).
A converter that adds an AMT network source advertises &quot;driad&quot;
discovery only for a source address whose reverse DNS zone carries an
AMT relay record, and otherwise names a relay service hostname in
<tt>relay</tt> with &quot;dns&quot; discovery (<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 4.2.1).</t>
<t><tt>timescale</tt>, the group-duration field and <tt>mmtpMode</tt> are required
fields (Section 12.1).  The converter takes <tt>timescale</tt> from
<tt>asset_timescale</tt> in the MP table when <tt>asset_timescale_flag</tt> is 1,
and uses 90 000 Hz when that flag is 0, as specified by
<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.3.9.3.  For each timed
Asset, it obtains the presentation time of each MPU's first AU in
presentation order from the PI document when PI is present;
ISO/IEC 23008-1 Clause 10.5.2.1 says that the MPU timestamp
descriptor is ignored in that case.  Otherwise it decodes each
descriptor's 64-bit NTP <tt>mpu_presentation_time</tt> value
(<xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> Clause 10.5.2) and does not treat the encoded NTP
integer as a media tick count.  It converts those presentation
instants through the selected asset/media clock, retaining the
authored media timing when NTP fractional quantization does not land
on an integer media tick.  That instant is not <tt>ticks</tt>
(Section 4.4.1) when the MPU has leading pictures: <tt>ticks</tt> is that
instant plus the difference between the authored composition times
(Section 5.1) of the MPU's first AU in decode order and its
earliest-presented AU, converted to the selected timescale as
Section 4.4.1 requires.</t>
<t>The converter derives the group duration from the authored MPU/media
cadence and validates it against those <tt>ticks</tt> values.  It may emit
<tt>groupDurationMs</tt> only when the conversion to the selected timescale
is an exact positive integer tick count; when the cadence is exact
only in ticks it emits <tt>groupDurationTicks</tt>.
The fixed-cadence profile cannot represent a source whose MPU cadence
is not one constant positive duration, so conversion fails rather
than rounding or inventing a cadence.  It sets <tt>mmtpMode</tt> itself.
The AL-FEC message does not name <tt>fec.blockProfile</tt>, which is
required for a track whose <tt>fec.algorithm</tt> is not &quot;none&quot;
(<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.1); for such a track the converter sets it to
&quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot;, the profile whose entry carries the coding byte 0x14
that the converter accepts (Section 8.3; <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 7.3).</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="security-considerations"><name>Security Considerations</name>
<t>MMT content protection uses Common Encryption (CENC) <xref target="ISO.23001-7"></xref>
which is preserved through MoQ transport.  The MMTP packet and
payload headers are not encrypted by CENC, so receivers, and MMTP
gateways outside MoQ, can inspect packet type, sequence, and
fragmentation metadata without accessing media sample content.  A MoQ
relay treats the object payload, MMTP headers included, as opaque
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 7.8) and never parses MMTP
(Section 6.2).</t>

<section anchor="multicast-security"><name>Multicast Security</name>
<t>Multicast-specific security considerations (source authentication,
replay protection, AMT relay trust) are defined in
<xref target="MOQ-MULTICAST"></xref> Section 7.</t>
</section>
</section>

<section anchor="iana-considerations"><name>IANA Considerations</name>
<t>This document defines the catalog <tt>packaging</tt> value &quot;mmtp&quot;
(Section 12.1), extending the allowed packaging values of the MOQT
Streaming Format <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.4 in the same
manner as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref>.  If a registry of packaging
values is established for that format, this document requests
registration of:</t>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Value</th>
<th>Description</th>
<th>Reference</th>
</tr>
</thead>

<tbody>
<tr>
<td>&quot;mmtp&quot;</td>
<td>MMTP packets carrying MPU/MFU payloads</td>
<td>This document</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table><t>This document requests no MoQ message type registrations.  FEC
signaling uses no MoQ control message (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 5.2); no
document in this suite requests a control-message codepoint.</t>
</section>

</middle>

<back>
<references><name>References</name>
<references><name>Normative References</name>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.ietf-moq-loc.xml"/>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.ietf-moq-msf.xml"/>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.ietf-moq-transport.xml"/>
<reference anchor="ISO.14496-12" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Information technology - Coding of audio-visual objects - Part 12: ISO base media file format</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ISO/IEC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2026"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ISO/IEC" value="14496-12:2026"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="ISO.23008-1" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Information technology - High efficiency coding and media delivery in heterogeneous environments - Part 1: MPEG media transport (MMT)</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ISO/IEC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2023"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ISO/IEC" value="23008-1:2023"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="ISO.23008-1.AMD1" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Information technology - High efficiency coding and media delivery in heterogeneous environments - Part 1: MPEG media transport (MMT) - Amendment 1: Signalling of adaptive FEC scheme</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ISO/IEC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2025" month="May"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ISO/IEC" value="23008-1:2023/Amd 1:2025"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="ISO.23008-10" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Information technology - High efficiency coding and media delivery in heterogeneous environments - Part 10: MPEG media transport forward error correction (FEC) codes</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ISO/IEC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2015"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ISO/IEC" value="23008-10:2015"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="MOQ-FEC" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Forward Error Correction for Media over QUIC</title>
    <author fullname="Omar Ramadan" initials="O." surname="Ramadan">
      <organization>Blockcast</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2026" month="October" day="26"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="Internet-Draft" value="draft-ramadan-moq-fec-01"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="MOQ-MULTICAST" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Multicast Delivery and Endpoint Discovery for Media over QUIC</title>
    <author fullname="Omar Ramadan" initials="O." surname="Ramadan">
      <organization>Blockcast</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2026" month="October" day="26"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="Internet-Draft" value="draft-ramadan-moq-multicast-01"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.2119.xml"/>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.6330.xml"/>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.8174.xml"/>
</references>
<references><name>Informative References</name>
<reference anchor="ARIB-B60" target="">
  <front>
    <title>MMT-Based Media Transport Scheme in Digital Broadcasting Systems</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ARIB</organization>
    </author>
    <date></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ARIB STD-B60" value="Version 1.14"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<reference anchor="ATSC-A331" target="https://www.atsc.org/atsc-documents/3312017-signaling-delivery-synchronization-error-protection/">
  <front>
    <title>Signaling, Delivery, Synchronization, and Error Protection</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ATSC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2026" month="February"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ATSC" value="A/331:2026-02"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml3/reference.I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf.xml"/>
<reference anchor="ISO.23001-7" target="">
  <front>
    <title>Information technology - MPEG systems technologies - Part 7: Common encryption in ISO base media file format files</title>
    <author>
      <organization>ISO/IEC</organization>
    </author>
    <date year="2023"></date>
  </front>
  <seriesInfo name="ISO/IEC" value="23001-7:2023"></seriesInfo>
</reference>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.5905.xml"/>
<xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.9706.xml"/>
</references>
</references>

<section anchor="changes-since-draft-ramadan-moq-mmt-00"><name>Changes Since draft-ramadan-moq-mmt-00</name>
<t>This appendix is informative.  It is to be removed before
publication as an RFC.</t>

<ul spacing="compact">
<li>Object IDs are numbered per group: 0 for the first object of a
group and one more for each later object in source order, across
subgroups, as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 6.2 requires.  In -00
they restarted at 0 in each subgroup, so several objects of one
group shared an Object ID, which <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref>
Section 2.1 does not allow (Sections 3.1, 4.1, 4.6, 5, 5.2, and 8).
Section 4.6 is retitled &quot;Object Identifier Assignment and
Reconstruction&quot;.</li>
<li>Section 4.1 states that an mmtp track maps one data unit, not one
object, to a stream, unlike <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 6, and
keeps the Group and Object numbering of its Sections 6.1 and 6.2.</li>
<li>The join (Section 6.1, step 3) uses the current-group join of
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.5: SUBSCRIBE with a Next
Object LOCATION_FILTER and FILL_PARAMETERS with StartGroup = 1.
Section 6.2 is now an informative note.  The relay replay and
completeness requirements of -00 are removed, because a publisher
must not send objects outside the requested range
(<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 3.3.1).</li>
<li>Section 4.4.1: an mmtp publisher, whose Group numbers follow media
time, does not set the DYNAMIC_GROUPS Track Property to 1, and
Section 6.1 notes that NEW_GROUP_REQUEST cannot shorten a wait for
the next group.  A publisher that skips Group numbers on a restart
signals the gap with PRIOR_GROUP_ID_GAP, as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref>
Section 6.1 recommends.</li>
<li>Section 6.1, step 1: the catalog is read through a subscription
that joins its current group, as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5
requires, and a switching-set disagreement is handled as
Section 4.4.2 specifies.</li>
<li>Section 4.3: objects of an mmtp track are sent in subgroups, not as
datagrams.  The permission for a relay to drop a subgroup under
congestion is removed; <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-transport"></xref> Section 5.2
governs when objects go undelivered.  Section 5.2.1 no longer refers
to datagram paths: on a lossy path a subsample data unit completes,
possibly after FEC recovery, or is discarded as incomplete, like any
other data unit.</li>
<li>Section 4.4: a repair track carries no <tt>altGroup</tt>, so it is not a
member of a switching set.  In -00 it carried the <tt>altGroup</tt> of the
track it protects, although its Groups are FEC blocks, not
media-time-aligned Groups.</li>
<li>Catalog initialization data uses the <tt>initDataList</tt> and <tt>initRef</tt>
fields of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> in place of the per-track <tt>initData</tt>
field, which the current revisions of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> and
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> do not define.  A receiver may still accept
<tt>initData</tt> from -00 implementations (Sections 4.5, 6.1, 12, and
12.1).</li>
<li>Switching sets (Sections 4.4 and 4.4.2): an intra-only mmtp track
may use a group duration that divides that of the GOP tracks a
whole number of times.  The exception applies to mmtp tracks only,
so cmaf members keep the Group number alignment of
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref> Section 3.2.  The g * n Group mapping is the
alternate mechanism of <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 4.2, and the
10^-3 tolerance only classifies a track as intra-only.</li>
<li>Section 4.4.2, Table 3: the optional <tt>timescale</tt> field of cmaf
tracks is attributed to <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> Section 5.2.21, not to
<xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref>.  A loc switching-set member, like a cmaf
one, carries a catalog <tt>timescale</tt>, which a TIMESCALE Property on
the track must equal, so <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-loc"></xref> is now a normative
reference.  A track entry without <tt>packaging</tt> is malformed.</li>
<li>Section 8.3: the AL-FEC message carries in
<tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt> the <xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> Table 1 code
point of the track's algorithm: 3 for &quot;raptorq&quot; and 1 for
&quot;reed-solomon&quot;.  Sections 7 and 8.1 follow <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref>, which now
fully specifies &quot;reed-solomon&quot; and makes it the mandatory-to-implement
scheme.  RaptorQ is optional there.  Section 7 states that neither
the MMT AL-FEC framework nor <xref target="ATSC-A331"></xref>, which uses it for MMTP
sessions, requires a particular code, so the codes are those
<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> specifies.
<xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> is now a normative reference.  The message's
<tt>length_of_repair_symbol</tt> carries the track's <tt>symbolSize</tt>, which
Section 12.2 reads back, and <tt>num_of_repair_symbol_per_packet</tt> is
1; its <tt>maximum_p_for_repair_flow</tt> carries the RSB_length of the
track's FEC instance, the block total, which Section 12.2 reads
back as <tt>repairSymbols</tt> less the layers above 0 it lists, listing
a layer it learns from provisioning only where provisioning places
it, with every other listed layer, above every layer it does not
list, keeping the value it first published for a track,
and those of the layers it has listed, across later versions of
the message that raise the field, retiring the source encoding
under one that lowers the field below the total its catalog
derives for the highest layer it lists (<xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section
6.3.9), appending at the next index a layer it learns from
provisioning after it published the track only where provisioning
places it next above the highest layer it lists with no unlearned
layer below it, the field's rise alone placing none, and listing
one provisioning does not so place, or whose symbols the field it
first read already counted, only by retiring the source encoding
and publishing a separate rendition.  Section 12.2 states that
the field is a bound in <xref target="ISO.23008-1"></xref> where
&quot;iso-ssbg1-v1&quot; carries P as every repair packet's RSB_length,
lists the repair track only once a repair packet of the flow
carries at least the field, and fails the conversion of a flow
whose repair packets carry an RSB_length below the field on a
block at or after, in the serial order of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section
7.5, one received carrying at least the field, since a publisher
that appends a layer sends the new version only after the last
repair packet generated under the previous total (Section 8.3)
while the path keeps no order between the message and the repair
flow (Section 5.2.2); once the track is published such a packet,
below the total its catalog derives for the highest layer it
lists, retires the source encoding, the separate rendition listing
the repair track again as the first listing did; a previous-total
packet of an earlier block fails a receiver of the catalog closed
on nothing, the own-track clause of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Section 6.3.9
applying to layers above 0 alone.  Section 8.3 sets the
entry's <tt>number_of_assets</tt> to 1, the one Asset being the source
track's.  Section 12.2 accepts only an entry with a
<tt>number_of_assets</tt> of 1, the coding byte 0x14 and code point 1 or
3, and fails the conversion of a flow whose <tt>fec</tt> object would fail
a catalog rule of <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> Sections 5.1 and 6.3.4 (a maximum K
or maximum P of 0, a symbol length below 14, a RaptorQ symbol
length that is not a multiple of 8, a RaptorQ maximum K above 56403
or maximum K plus maximum P above 2^24, a Reed-Solomon maximum K
plus maximum P above 255), of one whose repair flow is
packet_id 0, the flow's own packet_id or the packet_id of another
track of the session, and of the flows of two entries that name
one repair flow or list one Asset.</li>
<li>Section 1.1: the CARP row is removed.  CARP (draft-law-moq-carp-00)
has expired, and its content continues as <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-cmsf"></xref>.
The FEC column names the <xref target="MOQ-FEC"></xref> block profile for each
packaging, including &quot;moq-object-v1&quot; for loc and cmaf tracks.  The
section names MSF, LOC and CMSF with their references, and the cases
that suit each packaging are no longer stated with BCP 14 keywords.</li>
<li>Sections 12.2 and 12.3 and Appendix A of -00 (the S-TSID
conversion example): the S-TSID conversion of -00 is removed, and
this appendix of changes is now Appendix A.  This document targets
MMTP services and not ROUTE, so Section 12.2 now derives the
catalog from MMTP signaling,
the MP table and the AL-FEC message, there is no export to
broadcast signaling, and the Abstract, Section 1, Section 2 and
Section 7 no longer name S-TSID.  Section 7.2 no longer cites the
S-TSID <tt>fecOTI</tt> attribute and says the AL-FEC message carries no
OTI, and the Section 8.1 <tt>algorithm</tt> rule reads the code point from
<tt>fec_code_id_for_repair_flow</tt> alone, with no ROUTE-ingest case.</li>
<li>Sections 4.4.2 and 12.1: the example catalogs carry the fields
that <xref target="I-D.ietf-moq-msf"></xref> requires.</li>
<li>Section 13: a MoQ relay treats MMTP headers as opaque object
payload.</li>
<li>Editorial: abbreviations such as ISOBMFF, SSM, ASM, AMT,
ABR, GOP and OTI are expanded, and Section 2 defines AU.  Section 1
says &quot;FEC&quot; instead of &quot;Unified FEC&quot;.  Capitalized words that are not
BCP 14 keywords (NOT, LOW, NO) are lowercased.  Section 3.1 cites
<xref target="RFC5905"></xref> for the NTP short format, Section 9 cites <xref target="RFC9706"></xref>
for TreeDN, and Section 13 cites <xref target="ISO.23001-7"></xref> for Common
Encryption.  Section 14 uses the name &quot;MOQT Streaming Format&quot;.</li>
<li><xref target="ISO.14496-12"></xref> (ISOBMFF) is a normative reference, and
<xref target="ISO.23008-10"></xref> is dated.</li>
<li>References to the companion drafts point to their -01 revisions.</li>
</ul>
</section>

</back>

</rfc>
